The Powers of War and Peace: The Constitution and Foreign Affairs after 9/11

Note moyenne 3,09
( 33 avis fournis par Goodreads )
 
9780226960326: The Powers of War and Peace: The Constitution and Foreign Affairs after 9/11

Since the September 11 attacks on the United States, the Bush administration has come under fire for its methods of combating terrorism. Waging war against al Qaeda has proven to be a legal quagmire, with critics claiming that the administration's response in Afghanistan and Iraq is unconstitutional. The war on terror—and, in a larger sense, the administration's decision to withdraw from the ABM Treaty and the Kyoto accords—has many wondering whether the constitutional framework for making foreign affairs decisions has been discarded by the present administration.

John Yoo, formerly a lawyer in the Department of Justice, here makes the case for a completely new approach to understanding what the Constitution says about foreign affairs, particularly the powers of war and peace. Looking to American history, Yoo points out that from Truman and Korea to Clinton's intervention in Kosovo, American presidents have had to act decisively on the world stage without a declaration of war. They are able to do so, Yoo argues, because the Constitution grants the president, Congress, and the courts very different powers, requiring them to negotiate the country's foreign policy. Yoo roots his controversial analysis in a brilliant reconstruction of the original understanding of the foreign affairs power and supplements it with arguments based on constitutional text, structure, and history.

Accessibly blending historical arguments with current policy debates, The Powers of War and Peace will no doubt be hotly debated. And while the questions it addresses are as old and fundamental as the Constitution itself, America's response to the September 11 attacks has renewed them with even greater force and urgency.

“Can the president of the United States do whatever he likes in wartime without oversight from Congress or the courts? This year, the issue came to a head as the Bush administration struggled to maintain its aggressive approach to the detention and interrogation of suspected enemy combatants in the war on terrorism. But this was also the year that the administration’s claims about presidential supremacy received their most sustained intellectual defense [in] The Powers of War and Peace.”—Jeffrey Rosen, New York Times

“Yoo’s theory promotes frank discussion of the national interest and makes it harder for politicians to parade policy conflicts as constitutional crises. Most important, Yoo’s approach offers a way to renew our political system’s democratic vigor.”—David B. Rivkin Jr. and Carlos Ramos-Mrosovsky, National Review

Les informations fournies dans la section « Synopsis » peuvent faire référence à une autre édition de ce titre.

About the Author :

John Yoo is professor of law at Boalt Hall School of Law at the University of California, Berkeley, and a visiting scholar at the American Enterprise Institute. He served as general counsel of the Senate Judiciary Committee; as a law clerk to Justice Clarence Thomas and Judge Laurence H. Silberman; and, from 2001 to 2003, as a deputy assistant attorney general in the Office of Legal Counsel of the U.S. Department of Justice.

From The Washington Post :

John Yoo deserves much credit for helping open up a secretive subject for public discussion, even when it has meant unpleasantness for himself. As the apparent author of many of the Bush administration's post-9/11 policies, including those that authorize the National Security Agency (NSA) to violate the wiretap statute and strip Geneva Convention protections from anyone suspected of affiliation with al Qaeda and the Taliban, Yoo lives in a firestorm. In the past few months alone, international lawyers have called for his criminal indictment, students have broken into his classroom at Berkeley (where the former deputy assistant attorney general now teaches law) to stage a mock detainee hearing, and lecture halls where he is scheduled to speak have been boycotted. Such political grandstanding is shameful behavior; in fact, Yoo should be commended for not hiding behind the standard Washington cliché of saying, "That's classified; I can't talk about it."

Of course, much of Yoo's work for the Justice Department is indeed still classified, most important his opinions on NSA spying and those justifying the legality of a military trial system at Guantanamo Bay. Nevertheless, Yoo's new book is marketed as a defense of the administration's post-9/11 conduct. Yet the book doesn't really accomplish that, or even attempt it. Rather, it is a sometimes careful, academic work about presidential powers in wartime.

In particular, the book argues that the Constitution gives the president a much larger role in foreign affairs and military operations than the other two branches of the federal government, that the president does not need a congressional declaration of war before placing troops on the ground and that treaties ratified by the Senate have no legal impact unless Congress explicitly passes laws saying that they do.

In advancing these claims, the book is burdened by its strange attempt to mix constitutional claims grounded in the Founders' intent in 1787 with the practicalities of living in an age of terrorism. Either one can take the position of such conservative icons as Robert Bork and Justice Antonin Scalia -- that the original intentions of the Constitution's authors bind us today and changes can only come through amendment -- or hold the view of more liberal figures such as Justice Stephen Breyer that practical, functional considerations create a living Constitution that adapts as times change. Both are perfectly plausible. What isn't credible is a theory that cherry-picks from the two to advance a particular thesis. And that's exactly what Yoo does at times.

Yoo is at his best in skewering the academics who believe that Congress must formally declare war before the president can engage in military operations. After all, hundreds of U.S. military operations have occurred without a declaration of war. Yoo's argument here, and the history he marshals, is contribution enough. There have been no declarations of war since World War II, yet a majority of academics today still adhere to the position that such a declaration is required before troops can be deployed.

Unfortunately, Yoo goes further, explaining that the president would not be made all powerful by such a broad reading of his war-making power because Congress could cut off funds or pass legislation to end the war. Yet it isn't remotely plausible that Congress's funding power can check the president. As Yoo's main academic opponent, former Stanford Law School dean John Hart Ely explains in his book War and Responsibility, "Once the president had committed 'our boys' to the battlefield, it would become emotionally and politically difficult to vote to cut off their 'support.' " If the legislative branch really did use its funding power in the way Yoo advertises, it would destroy his thesis, which is built on the speed, unity and decisiveness of the executive branch compared to Congress. It is jarring to watch a sober realist like Yoo ignore the obvious reality that Congress is incapable of defunding a war when troops are already engaged.

In the end, the most glaring failure of the book is its one-sided attack on the courts and Congress, with no real attention paid to the failures of the executive branch. The underlying message is that the executive doesn't need checks on its activities, but that the other branches consistently do. Yet presidents of both parties have made tremendous mistakes, and recent events have shown that claims of unchecked power can lead to massive abuse. Yoo even unwittingly refers to at least one recent miscalculation, in words that already date the book, by stating that Iraq was "potentially armed with weapons of mass destruction."

If scholars like Yoo want to exalt the executive, they will have to do a better job of figuring out ways to develop checks and balances inside the executive branch. Otherwise, faith in the executive is little more than a recipe for unaccountable and poor decisionmaking. This wasn't the way the Constitution was written; and I, for one, have more faith in our Founders than that.

Reviewed by Neal Katyal
Copyright 2006, The Washington Post. All Rights Reserved.

Les informations fournies dans la section « A propos du livre » peuvent faire référence à une autre édition de ce titre.

Meilleurs résultats de recherche sur AbeBooks

1.

Yoo, John
Edité par Univ. Of Chicago, Chicago (2005)
ISBN 10 : 0226960323 ISBN 13 : 9780226960326
Neuf(s) Paperback Quantité : 1
Vendeur
Valley Books
(Amherst, MA, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre Univ. Of Chicago, Chicago, 2005. Paperback. État : New. 366pp. Size: 8vo - over 7¾" - 9¾" tall. N° de réf. du libraire 070922

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 5,80
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 3,29
Vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais

2.

John Yoo
Edité par University of Chicago press
ISBN 10 : 0226960323 ISBN 13 : 9780226960326
Neuf(s) Quantité : > 20
Vendeur
INDOO
(Avenel, NJ, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre University of Chicago press. État : New. Brand New. N° de réf. du libraire 0226960323

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 12,57
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 2,92
Vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais

3.

Yoo, John
ISBN 10 : 0226960323 ISBN 13 : 9780226960326
Neuf(s) Quantité : 10
Vendeur
Paperbackshop-US
(Wood Dale, IL, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre 2006. PAP. État : New. New Book. Shipped from US within 10 to 14 business days. Established seller since 2000. N° de réf. du libraire TX-9780226960326

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 15,13
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 3,33
Vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais

4.

Yoo
Edité par Univ of Chicago
ISBN 10 : 0226960323 ISBN 13 : 9780226960326
Neuf(s) Couverture souple Quantité : 1
Vendeur
C. Clayton Thompson - Bookseller
(BOONE, NC, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre Univ of Chicago. État : BRAND NEW. BRAND NEW Softcover A Brand New Quality Book from a Full-Time Bookshop in business since 1992!. N° de réf. du libraire 2550061

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 19,71
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : Gratuit
Vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais

5.

John Yoo
Edité par The University of Chicago Press, United States (2006)
ISBN 10 : 0226960323 ISBN 13 : 9780226960326
Neuf(s) Paperback Quantité : 10
Vendeur
Book Depository hard to find
(London, Royaume-Uni)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre The University of Chicago Press, United States, 2006. Paperback. État : New. New edition. Language: English . This book usually ship within 10-15 business days and we will endeavor to dispatch orders quicker than this where possible. Brand New Book. Since the September 11 attacks on the United States, the Bush administration has come under fire for its methods of combating terrorism. Waging war against al Qaeda has proven to be a legal quagmire, with critics claiming that the administration s response in Afghanistan and Iraq is unconstitutional. The war on terror--and, in a larger sense, the administration s decision to withdraw from the ABM Treaty and the Kyoto accords--has many wondering whether the constitutional framework for making foreign affairs decisions has been discarded by the present administration. John Yoo, formerly a lawyer in the Department of Justice, here makes the case for a completely new approach to understanding what the Constitution says about foreign affairs, particularly the powers of war and peace. Looking to American history, Yoo points out that from Truman and Korea to Clinton s intervention in Kosovo, American presidents have had to act decisively on the world stage without a declaration of war. They are able to do so, Yoo argues, because the Constitution grants the president, Congress, and the courts very different powers, requiring them to negotiate the country s foreign policy. Yoo roots his controversial analysis in a brilliant reconstruction of the original understanding of the foreign affairs power and supplements it with arguments based on constitutional text, structure, and history. Accessibly blending historical arguments with current policy debates, The Powers of War and Peace will no doubt be hotly debated. And while the questions it addresses are as old and fundamental as the Constitution itself, America s response to the September 11 attacks has renewed them with even greater force and urgency. Can the president of the United States do whatever he likes in wartime without oversight from Congress or the courts? This year, the issue came to a head as the Bush administration struggled to maintain its aggressive approach to the detention and interrogation of suspected enemy combatants in the war on terrorism. But this was also the year that the administration s claims about presidential supremacy received their most sustained intellectual defense [in] The Powers of War and Peace. --Jeffrey Rosen, New York Times Yoo s theory promotes frank discussion of the national interest and makes it harder for politicians to parade policy conflicts as constitutional crises. Most important, Yoo s approach offers a way to renew our political system s democratic vigor. --David B. Rivkin Jr. and Carlos Ramos-Mrosovsky, National Review. N° de réf. du libraire BTE9780226960326

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 23,60
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : Gratuit
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais

6.

John Yoo
Edité par Univ of Chicago Pr (2006)
ISBN 10 : 0226960323 ISBN 13 : 9780226960326
Neuf(s) Couverture souple Quantité : 2
Vendeur
European-Media-Service Mannheim
(Mannheim, Allemagne)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre Univ of Chicago Pr, 2006. État : New. N° de réf. du libraire TV9780226960326

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 24,13
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 2,99
De Allemagne vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais

7.

John Yoo
Edité par University Of Chicago Press (2006)
ISBN 10 : 0226960323 ISBN 13 : 9780226960326
Neuf(s) Paperback Quantité : 1
Vendeur
Ergodebooks
(RICHMOND, TX, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre University Of Chicago Press, 2006. Paperback. État : New. N° de réf. du libraire DADAX0226960323

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 28,94
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 7,50
Vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais

8.

Yoo, John
Edité par University Of Chicago Press (2006)
ISBN 10 : 0226960323 ISBN 13 : 9780226960326
Neuf(s) Paperback Quantité : 2
Vendeur
Murray Media
(North Miami Beach, FL, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre University Of Chicago Press, 2006. Paperback. État : New. Never used!. N° de réf. du libraire P110226960323

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 35,26
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 1,66
Vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais

9.

John Yoo
Edité par Univ of Chicago Pr (2006)
ISBN 10 : 0226960323 ISBN 13 : 9780226960326
Neuf(s) Paperback Quantité : 1
Vendeur
Revaluation Books
(Exeter, Royaume-Uni)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre Univ of Chicago Pr, 2006. Paperback. État : Brand New. 366 pages. 9.00x6.00x1.25 inches. In Stock. N° de réf. du libraire 0226960323

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 36,11
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 6,76
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais

10.

John Yoo
ISBN 10 : 0226960323 ISBN 13 : 9780226960326
Neuf(s) Paperback Quantité : 1
Vendeur
AussieBookSeller
(SILVERWATER, NSW, Australie)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre 2006. Paperback. État : New. New edition. Paperback. Since the September 11 attacks on the United States, the Bush administration has come under fire for its methods of combating terrorism. Waging war against al Qaeda has proven.Shipping may be from our Sydney, NSW warehouse or from our UK or US warehouse, depending on stock availability. 366 pages. 0.553. N° de réf. du libraire 9780226960326

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 29,20
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 30,85
De Australie vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais

autres exemplaires de ce livre sont disponibles

Afficher tous les résultats pour ce livre