Articles liés à Why Socrates Died: Dispelling the Myths

Why Socrates Died: Dispelling the Myths - Couverture rigide

 
9780571235506: Why Socrates Died: Dispelling the Myths
Afficher les exemplaires de cette édition ISBN
 
 
Extrait :
Preface

Everyone has heard of Socrates, and even if they know little or nothing else about the man, they usually know that he was put to death by his fellow Athenians in 399 BCE. The events surrounding Socrates’ death have become iconic — more discussed, portrayed or merely mentioned — than any except those surrounding the death, some four hundred years later, of a Jewish prophet called Yehoshua. In fact, the two trials and executions often seem to meld in people’s minds, so that Socrates too becomes a kind of martyr — a good man unjustly killed for his views, or for being an outstanding individual in a collectivist society, or something like that. Do a web search for ‘Socrates and Jesus’ and you will see what I mean. But Socrates would have been the last to want to leave a cultural icon unexamined, and that is what I do in this book: examine all the evidence in order to reach a fuller understanding of Socrates’ trial and execution than has been achieved before.

Socrates’ trial was a critical moment in ancient Athenian history, and so provides a very good lens through which to study a complex and perennially fascinating, somewhat alien society. That is my second intention: to provide a readable account of as much Athenian history as is necessary to fill in the background of the trial. For we will, of course, never understand the trial without being able to enter, as fully as possible, into the mindset of the Athenians who condemned him to death. This is a book about classical Athenian society as much as it is about Socrates, and especially about the social crisis that Athens endured in the decades immediately preceding Socrates’ trial.

Socrates was famous: we have more evidence about him, and about Alcibiades, his beloved (who also features prominently in this book), than any other two figures from classical Athens. But even this good fortune may be two-edged. Socrates himself wrote nothing, and almost all the evidence about him comes from two of his followers, Plato and Xenophon, both of whom had their own agendas and reasons for writing. Among these reasons was a desire to exculpate their mentor — to make their fellow Athenians wonder why they ever condemned him to death (in this respect, at least, he truly resembles Jesus). So we may have a greater number of words about Socrates than about any comparable ancient Athenian, but every single word needs to be weighed and treated with caution. And the same goes for Alcibiades, a flamboyant, larger-than-life character whose image became exaggerated over the years, until he became an archetypal dandy, profligate and sexual omnivore, whose tyrannical political intentions could be read off from his private life. As if the dubious source material did not make the work difficult enough, at the heart of this book is a trial. The nature of Athenian society, and of the legal system in particular, means that very few trials — and none of those on social charges such as those of which Socrates was accused — were concerned only with the explicit charges. So all the evidence needs a judicious approach.

Socrates himself wrote nothing, as I have said, and there is a temptation to understand this as an eloquent way of asserting his mistrust of the written word. It is true that he preferred the flexibility of living conversation and the spark of pre-verbal knowledge that can occasionally be transmitted in such circumstances, but it is more to the point to remember that disseminating one’s ideas by means of the written word was still very rare in his day. But he did have views and opinions, and we need to unearth them from the pages of those who wrote about him, while recognizing that it will never finally be possible to disentangle Socrates’ own views from those of his followers.

I have long believed that the historical Socrates is pretty irrecoverable, but also that it would be sheer stupidity to deny that he cast a shadow over the works of Xenophon and Plato. Scholars often cling hopefully or desperately to a distinction between the ‘historical’ Socrates of Plato’s earlier dialogues, and the character ‘Socrates’ who seems to speak for Plato’s own ideas in later dialogues. I no longer believe in this distinction, except that in the light of Plato’s genius the shadow of the historical Socrates becomes harder to discern; but in order not to beg the question, I have avoided using Plato’s later dialogues for anything except corroborative evidence. I make far more use of Xenophon’s testimony than has been normal in the scholarly study of Socrates for the past hundred or so years — but I have already groused enough in print about the neglect of Xenophon, so I will say now only that without his help we are never going to gain a rounded picture of Socrates, or even of just his trial.

Socrates was a philosopher, one of the most influential the world has ever seen. Naturally, then, in this book I make quite a bit of use of philosophical texts. But I do not want to alarm any reader who associates ‘philosophy’ with ‘density and complexity’, or even with ‘futility’. Neither of these is a fair reaction to the majority of the ancient philosophers, for whom philosophy was, above all, a practical exercise in self-improvement. These early philosophers were dealing with real issues, problems arising from real life, so their work was not futile; many of them were trying in part to reach the ordinary educated man, and when they were making this attempt they did not write with density and complexity. At any rate, the Socratic works of Plato and Xenophon should more properly be classified as intelligent fiction than as tough philosophical textbooks.

In any case, this book is a work of history, and I scarcely scratch the surface of Socrates’ philosophy. But in locating political concerns at the heart of Socrates’ enterprise, I do present a revisionist picture of his thought. In this book, however, I write not as a philosopher but as a historian, and from a historian’s point of view the evidence for a more politically engaged Socrates is as plentiful as that for many reconstructions of the period.
Revue de presse :
"[This] deeply engaging book takes a historian's scalpel to the myths. Richly detailed, briskly written, it fills in the bloodstained background of Athens around 400 BC."
The Independent (U.K.)

"What a history . . . Like most good stories, it allows for a number of morals."
Globe and Mail

"Most incisive and readable . . . both learned and lively."
Irish Times

"It's ancient history, to be sure, but also highly instructive for the present day."
Winnipeg Free Press

"A surprisingly entertaining account of the period."
— Montreal Gazette

"Remarkable and thoroughly original. . . . [Waterfield] has given his narrative a cinematic sweep."
Christian Science Monitor

"The cleverness of Waterfield's richly told and enjoyable book is that he uses the death of Socrates as a way of introducing a wonderfully full picture of Athens in the fifth century."
The Guardian

Les informations fournies dans la section « A propos du livre » peuvent faire référence à une autre édition de ce titre.

  • ÉditeurFaber & Faber
  • Date d'édition2009
  • ISBN 10 0571235506
  • ISBN 13 9780571235506
  • ReliureRelié
  • Nombre de pages288
  • Evaluation vendeur
Acheter D'occasion
état :  Assez bon
The book has been read, but is... En savoir plus sur cette édition

Frais de port : EUR 5,61
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis

Destinations, frais et délais

Ajouter au panier

Autres éditions populaires du même titre

9780393065275: Why Socrates Died – Dispelling the Myths

Edition présentée

ISBN 10 :  ISBN 13 :  9780393065275
Editeur : W. W. Norton & Co., 2009
Couverture rigide

  • 9780571235513: Why Socrates Died: Dispelling the Myths

    Faber ..., 2010
    Couverture souple

  • 9780771088520: Why Socrates Died: Dispelling the Myths

    Couverture souple

  • 9780771088513: Why Socrates Died: Dispelling the Myths

    McClel..., 2009
    Couverture rigide

Meilleurs résultats de recherche sur AbeBooks

Image d'archives

Waterfield, Robin
Edité par Faber and Faber (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0571235506 ISBN 13 : 9780571235506
Ancien ou d'occasion Couverture rigide Quantité disponible : 2
Vendeur :
WorldofBooks
(Goring-By-Sea, WS, Royaume-Uni)
Evaluation vendeur

Description du livre Hardback. Etat : Very Good. The book has been read, but is in excellent condition. Pages are intact and not marred by notes or highlighting. The spine remains undamaged. N° de réf. du vendeur GOR005385913

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Contacter le vendeur

Acheter D'occasion
EUR 2,46
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 5,61
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais
Image d'archives

Waterfield, Robin
Edité par Faber and Faber (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0571235506 ISBN 13 : 9780571235506
Ancien ou d'occasion Couverture rigide Quantité disponible : 1
Vendeur :
WorldofBooks
(Goring-By-Sea, WS, Royaume-Uni)
Evaluation vendeur

Description du livre Hardback. Etat : Good. The book has been read but remains in clean condition. All pages are intact and the cover is intact. Some minor wear to the spine. N° de réf. du vendeur GOR008435219

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Contacter le vendeur

Acheter D'occasion
EUR 2,46
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 5,61
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais
Image fournie par le vendeur

Waterfield, Robin
Edité par Faber & Faber (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0571235506 ISBN 13 : 9780571235506
Ancien ou d'occasion Couverture rigide Quantité disponible : 1
Vendeur :
WeBuyBooks
(Rossendale, LANCS, Royaume-Uni)
Evaluation vendeur

Description du livre Etat : Good. Most items will be dispatched the same or the next working day. A tan to the pages. N° de réf. du vendeur wbs3573771329

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Contacter le vendeur

Acheter D'occasion
EUR 2,64
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 9,36
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais
Image d'archives

Waterfield, Robin
Edité par Faber & Faber (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0571235506 ISBN 13 : 9780571235506
Ancien ou d'occasion Couverture rigide Quantité disponible : 1
Vendeur :
Bestsellersuk
(Hereford, Royaume-Uni)
Evaluation vendeur

Description du livre Hardcover. Etat : Acceptable. Book is slightly warped. Minor bumping to edges Slight scratches to dust jacket. Slight tear to Dust Jacket. Sun Damage to edge of Pages. No.1 BESTSELLERS - great prices, friendly customer service â " all orders are dispatched next working day. N° de réf. du vendeur mon0000709661

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Contacter le vendeur

Acheter D'occasion
EUR 2,83
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 14,04
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais
Image d'archives

Robin Waterfield
ISBN 10 : 0571235506 ISBN 13 : 9780571235506
Ancien ou d'occasion Couverture rigide Edition originale Quantité disponible : 1
Vendeur :
The London Bookworm
(East Sussex, Royaume-Uni)
Evaluation vendeur

Description du livre Cloth. Etat : Fine. Etat de la jaquette : Near Fine. First Edition. Hardback. First Edition. Why Socrates Died.A renowned classicist and the translator of such thinkers as Plutarch, Plato, and Xenophon, Robin Waterfield here reconsiders the most famous trial and execution in Western civilization. As Waterfield recounts the story, the charges against Socrates of impiety and corrupting the youth of Athens were already enough for a death sentence, but the prosecutors accused him of more, including mentoring those responsible for defeat in the Peloponnesian War. Waterfield demonstrates that there was a great deal of truth, from an Athenian perspective, in these charges, but more importantly, he is able in this context to remove layers of myth from the event and give us a clearer portrait of Socrates himself."The analysis will surprise readers accustomed to viewing Socrates' accusers as paranoid defenders of religious superstitions. For a careful parsing of the evidence reveals that when Athenian judges condemned Socrates, they were defending principles still cherished by most 21st-century readers: namely, the principles of democracy. Waterfield convincingly establishes that Socrates fell under hostile suspicion largely because of his close ties to young students of deeply anti-democratic sympathies. One of these arrogant young men joined other oligarchs in conspiring against Athens during its bitter war against Sparta; another scripted the atrocities committed by the Thirty Tyrants when they temporarily overthrew Athens' democratic government. Waterfield shows that even Socrates' own belief in an ideal government by experts legitimated elitist, not democratic, governance. Such a belief, readers soon realize, would have appeared particularly menacing to Athenian democrats traumatized by the twin shocks of external assault and internal discord. Impressive scholarship redefining an iconic event." Contents: List of Illustrations. Preface. Acknowledgements. Key Dates. Maps. The Trial of Socrates. The War Years. Crisis and Conflict. The Condemnation of Socrates. Glossary. References. Bibliography. Index. Illustrated. (We carry a wide selection of titles in The Arts, Theology, History, Politics, Social and Physical Sciences. academic and scholarly books and Modern First Editions ,and all types of Academic Literature.). N° de réf. du vendeur 091107

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Contacter le vendeur

Acheter D'occasion
EUR 10,41
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 21,05
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais
Image d'archives

Robin Waterfield
Edité par Faber & Faber (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0571235506 ISBN 13 : 9780571235506
Ancien ou d'occasion Couverture rigide Quantité disponible : 1
Vendeur :
The Swift Bookstore
(Peterlee, Royaume-Uni)
Evaluation vendeur

Description du livre Hardcover. Etat : Very Good. BRAND NEW copy just the lightest shelfwear to jacket from shop & light mark to fore-edge. Our very last copy. We endeavour to send orders as quickly as possible & in most cases are sent by first available post 6 days a week. (860-550). N° de réf. du vendeur GG-95UQ-GWHB

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Contacter le vendeur

Acheter D'occasion
EUR 11,99
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 20
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais
Image d'archives

Robin Waterfield
Edité par Faber and Faber (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0571235506 ISBN 13 : 9780571235506
Ancien ou d'occasion Couverture rigide Quantité disponible : 1
Vendeur :
Y-Not-Books
(Hereford, Royaume-Uni)
Evaluation vendeur

Description du livre Hardcover. Etat : Good. Bumped edges and book is warped Second Hand,cover is considerably worn and torn,has been well read and used,pages are sun damaged but contents are complete MAY HAVE PREVIOUS OWNER'S INSCRIPTION Torn Dust Jacket Next day dispatch. International delivery available. 1000's of satisfied customers! Please contact us with any enquiries. N° de réf. du vendeur mon0000321705

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Contacter le vendeur

Acheter D'occasion
EUR 19,79
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 14,04
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais
Image fournie par le vendeur

Robin Waterfield
Edité par Faber and Faber (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0571235506 ISBN 13 : 9780571235506
Ancien ou d'occasion Couverture rigide Edition originale Quantité disponible : 1
Vendeur :
Hall of Books
(Shropshire, Royaume-Uni)
Evaluation vendeur

Description du livre Hardback. Etat : Fine. Etat de la jaquette : Fine. 1st. First edition first impression hardback, 2009, with unclipped jacket. In overall fine, unread conditionp. Binding tight and appears almost unopened. Internally clean, no annotation or inscriptions - small name and address label to front endpaper; text and illustrations bright and clear throughout. Photographs available. Not an old library book. N° de réf. du vendeur 230270

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Contacter le vendeur

Acheter D'occasion
EUR 24,04
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 18,66
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais
Image d'archives

WATERFIELD, R.,
Edité par Faber and Faber (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0571235506 ISBN 13 : 9780571235506
Ancien ou d'occasion Couverture rigide Quantité disponible : 1
Vendeur :
Evaluation vendeur

Description du livre Etat : Antiquarian. Faber and Faber, London, 2009. XXV,253p. Hardbound wrps. Nice copy. Au milieu de tant de scories qui encombrent les catalogues de maisons d'édition sur un tel sujet, voici un bon livre. On y retrouve cette qualité d'écriture inaccoutumée en de tels ouvrages qu'on avait déjà appréciée avec le précédent livre de Robin Waterfield sur l'Anabase de Xénophon, elle allie clarté et précision et rend la lecture toujours très agréable, souvent originale, une lecture enrichissante en raison aussi de la bonne maîtrise du dossier par l'auteur. (PIERRE BRULÉ in Bryn Mawr Classical Review 2009.10.30). Antiquarian. N° de réf. du vendeur 32941

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Contacter le vendeur

Acheter D'occasion
EUR 18,50
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 25
De Pays-Bas vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais
Image d'archives

Robin Waterfield
Edité par Faber and Faber, London (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0571235506 ISBN 13 : 9780571235506
Ancien ou d'occasion Couverture rigide Quantité disponible : 1
Vendeur :
St Paul's Bookshop P.B.F.A.
(Peterborough, Royaume-Uni)
Evaluation vendeur

Description du livre Hardcover. Etat : Near Fine. Etat de la jaquette : Near Fine. Fine hardback copy in jacket. Excellent condition. LISTING PHOTO DOES NOT NECESSARILY MATCH THIS COPY. N° de réf. du vendeur 040396

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Contacter le vendeur

Acheter D'occasion
EUR 12,05
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 35,09
De Royaume-Uni vers Etats-Unis
Destinations, frais et délais

There are autres exemplaires de ce livre sont disponibles

Afficher tous les résultats pour ce livre