Paul Johnson Churchill

ISBN 13 : 9780670021055

Churchill

Note moyenne 3,79
( 2 423 avis fournis par GoodReads )
 
9780670021055: Churchill
Extrait :

Chapter Six
Supreme Power and Frustration

As prime minister and minister of defense, Churchill held power "in ever growing measure," as he himself put it, from May 1940 to July 1945. Probably no statesman in British history had held power for so long in so concentrated and extensive a form. So the first question to ask is: Did Churchill personally save Britain? Was his leadership essential to its survival and eventual victory?

The question is best answered by examining the factors and virtues which operated in his favor—some determined by objective events, others by his own genius and exertions. They were tenfold. First, as a civilian leader, Churchill benefited from a change of national opinion toward the relative trustworthiness of politicians and service leaders—"frocks and brass hats," to use the phrase of his youth. In the First World War, reverence for brass hats and dislike of frocks made it almost impossible for the government, even under Lloyd George at his apotheosis, to conduct the war efficiently. As Churchill put it: "The foolish doctrine was preached to the public through innumerable agencies that generals and admirals must be right on war matters and civilians of all kinds must be wrong—inculcated billionfold by the newspapers under the crudest forms." Lloyd George had the greatest difficulty in sacking any senior figure in uniform and could never take the risk of sacking Haig, the army supremo on the western front, much as he would have liked to.

By World War II, the truth about the mistakes of the brass hats in the earlier conflict had sunk so deeply into the national consciousness that the position had been almost reversed. There was no war hero until Montgomery made himself one late in the conflict by his own victories. Churchill by contrast came to power with the reputation of having been right throughout the thirties, and was now proved right by the danger in which Britain found herself. He never had to hesitate, except for genuine reasons, before sacking a general, even a popular one like Archibald Wavell, the British commander in Egypt. He felt his authority and exercised it: he was seen walking up and down the empty cabinet room once, after a major sacking, saying aloud, "I want them all to feel my power." Churchill was overwhelmingly admired, even loved, but also feared.

Second, the concentration of power in Churchill's person, with the backing of all parties, meant that there were never any practical or constitutional obstacles to the right decisions being taken. He always behaved with absolute propriety. He told the king everything and listened to all he said: within months George VI had swung right round in his favor and wrote, "I could not possibly have a better Prime Minister." He also observed all the cabinet procedural rules. Above all, he treated Parliament, especially the House of Commons, with reverence and made it plain he was merely its servant. These were not mere formulae. Insofar as Churchill had a religion, it was the British constitution, spirit and letter: Parliament was the church in which he worshipped and whose decisions he obeyed. All this balanced and sanctified the huge power he possessed and exercised. Unlike Hitler, he operated from within a structure which represented, and was seen and felt to represent, the nation. He was never a dictator, and the awful example of Hitler was ever present before him to prevent him from ever acting like one. This was particularly important in his relations with his service chiefs, such as General Alanbrooke, Admiral Cunningham, and Air Marshal Portal. He and the cabinet took the decisions about the war. But the way in which they were executed was left to the service chiefs. Churchill might cajole and bully, storm and rant, but in the end he always meticulously stuck to the rule and left the responsible senior chiefs to take the decisions. This was the opposite of Hitler's methods, and one principal reason why he lost the war. In another key respect Churchill did the opposite of Hitler: all his orders, without exception, were in writing and were absolutely clear. When issued verbally they were immediately confirmed in written form. All Hitler's orders were verbal and transmitted by aides: "It is the Führer's wish…; " Churchill's system of clear written orders, and his punctiliousness in observing the demarcation lines between civilian and military responsibility, is one reason the service chiefs were so loyal to him and his leadership, and indeed revered him, however much his working methods—especially his late hours— might try their patience and bodies.

Third, Churchill was personally fortunate in that he took over at a desperate time. The sheer power of the Nazi war machine, against which he had warned, was now revealed. The worst, as it were, had happened, was happening, or was about to happen. He was able to say in perfect truth, just after he took power (May 13, 1940), "I would say to the House, as I said to those who have joined the government, 'I have nothing to offer but blood, toil, tears and sweat.' " He added, in the same speech, that his aim was quite simple and clear: "Victory at all costs, victory in spite of all terror, victory, however long and hard the road may be; for without victory there is no survival." The last words were of deadly significance, and felt to be so. For Britain was not facing defeat in the sense that it had been defeated in the American War of Independence. It was facing extinction as a free country. Ordinary people were made to feel that. On Churchill's orders, the national anthems of the Allies were played on the BBC before the 9:00 p.m. news every Sunday. There were seven of them, six already defeated, occupied, and under the total control of the Gestapo. Soon, France joined the losers. Churchill certainly did all in his power to save her, paying five perilous visits to consult with her disintegrating, scared, and defeatist government and service chiefs. He would not, however—and rightly—go beyond a certain point. He was prepared to offer France a union of the two states, a most imaginative and adventurous idea, characteristic of his fertility. He was not willing, however, to comply with their request to send all of Britain's precious fighter squadrons to France in a despairing effort to stem the Nazi blitzkrieg. That, he said, would be "hurling snowballs into Hell." Instead, as France lurched toward dishonorable surrender and puppet status under Marshal Pétain, Churchill concentrated on getting the British Expeditionary Force safely back home. And he succeeded. Nine-tenths were rescued from Dunkirk, and many Allied soldiers with them, more than three hundred thousand in all, brought back by an improvised armada of ships, great and small, including pleasure cruisers and fishing boats, which gave picturesque color and even romance to the story, a typically British tale of snatching victory from the jaws of defeat. Thus within a month of taking office, amid the unmitigated catastrophe of France's fall, Churchill was able to report a British victory—Dunkirk—and to speak glowingly of "the Dunkirk spirit." It was in a sense a bogus victory, for the troops had been forced to leave their heavy equipment behind, and in many cases even their rifles, which they had smashed before embarking. But Dunkirk nevertheless gave a huge boost to British morale: now that Churchill was in charge, the people felt that, far from plunging further down into the abyss, the country was moving upward, if only an inch at a time.

Fourth, Churchill himself began to set a personal example of furious and productive activity at Ten Downing Street. He was sixty-five but he looked, seemed—was, indeed—the embodiment of energy. He worked a sixteen-hour day. He sought to make everyone else do likewise. In contrast to lethargic, self-indulgent old Asquith ("the bridge-player at the Wharf," as Churchill called him) or even Lloyd George, who had high tea instead of a proper dinner to discus strategy and went to bed at nine o'clock, Churchill began to wear his own form of labor-saving uniform, a siren suit, easy to put on or take off, in which he could nap if he wanted during long nighttime spells at work. This added hugely to the fast-accumulating Churchill legend: the public called it his "rompers." In fact, thanks to Clemmie, some of these siren suits were of elaborate and costly materials, velvet and silk as well as wool—for "best" parties in the Number Ten bombproof dining room, and so on. Churchill had always used clothes for personal propaganda and had a propensity to collect unusual uniforms. Since 1913 he had been an elder brother of Trinity House, a medieval institution which supervised all lighthouses and port lights in the British Isles. Its uniform had a distinctive nautical flavor and for court dress he always wore it in preference to that of his Privy Council. General de Gaulle, who had by now taken charge of France's resistance forces, asked him what it was and received the mystifying reply, "Je suis un frère aîné de la Sainte Trinité." But the siren suit was the everyday wartime wear and proved a masterstroke of propaganda. In it the prime minister worked within days of taking over, as the first brief and pointed memos and orders flowed out under the famous headline: "Action This Day." So did the endless series of brief, urgent queries: "Pray inform me on one half-sheet of paper, why…; " Answers had to be given, fast. Churchill had teams of what he called "dictation secretaries." He worked them very long hours. He was sometimes brusque or angry, swore, forgot their names, even lost his temper. But he also smiled, joked, dazzled them with uproarious charm and whimsicalities. They all loved him and were proud to work with him. They helped him to t...

Revue de presse :

"It turns out that while Wikipedia can ably trace the arc of Churchill's life, Johnson...can give the reader the definite sense of having known Churchill, or at least of having hung out with him for a bit... Churchill lets you spend some time in the man's company, and who wouldn't want that?"
- New York Times Book Review

"Paul Johnson is the most celebrated and best-loved British historian in America."
- Wall Street Journal

"[If] you appreciate clarity, authority, and verve in historical writing, you will understand why I gulped down [ Churchill] and now declare it the most exciting biography I read in 2009."

-Jesse Kornbluth, Huffington Post

"Johnson clearly shares and revels in Churchill's generosity of spirit and limitless intellectual energy. He has produced a book that is a joy--and a worthy tribute to both of them."
- Washington Times

"You read Johnson to be provoked and entertained, and on both these scores his biography, like its subject, succeeds wonderfully."
- The American COnservative

"With deft narrative skill and keen insight, Johnson masterfully sketches the phases of Churchill's life...Along the way, Johnson gives us wonderful insights into Churchill's character...Rich with anecdote and quotation, Paul Johnson's Churchill illustrates the man's humor, resilience, courage, and eccentricity as no other biography before."
- National Review

Johnson's story arc is written in fluid prose that beautifully reveals the tension of achievement of Churchill's life."
-Dallas Morning News

"The book's most original offering is--in characteristically vivid prose and a consistent intelligence and urbanity--Johnson's distillation of life lessons from Churchill's storied career."
-Jon Meacham, Slate.com

Les informations fournies dans la section « A propos du livre » peuvent faire référence à une autre édition de ce titre.

Meilleurs résultats de recherche sur AbeBooks

1.

Johnson, Paul
Edité par Viking
ISBN 10 : 0670021059 ISBN 13 : 9780670021055
Neuf(s) Couverture rigide Quantité : 1
Vendeur
Your Online Bookstore
(Houston, TX, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre Viking. Hardcover. État : New. 0670021059 Ships promptly from Texas. N° de réf. du libraire HCI5105SGGG030217H0219A

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 7,82
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 4,58
De Etats-Unis vers France
Destinations, frais et délais

2.

Paul Johnson
Edité par Viking (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0670021059 ISBN 13 : 9780670021055
Neuf(s) Couverture rigide Edition originale Quantité : 1
Vendeur
Ergodebooks
(RICHMOND, TX, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre Viking, 2009. Hardcover. État : New. 1st. N° de réf. du libraire DADAX0670021059

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 14,83
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 12,95
De Etats-Unis vers France
Destinations, frais et délais

3.

Johnson, Paul
Edité par Viking (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0670021059 ISBN 13 : 9780670021055
Neuf(s) Couverture rigide Edition originale Quantité : 1
Vendeur
Frank Sincavage
(PHILA, PA, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre Viking, 2009. Hardcover. État : New. Etat de la jaquette : New. First Edition; First Printing. DJ has a closed tearfront top ; Mylar covered; 8vo 8" - 9" tall; 192 pages. N° de réf. du libraire 41349

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 7,62
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 21,27
De Etats-Unis vers France
Destinations, frais et délais

4.

Paul Johnson
ISBN 10 : 0670021059 ISBN 13 : 9780670021055
Neuf(s) Quantité : 1
Vendeur
LVeritas
(Newton, MA, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre État : New. N° de réf. du libraire 36SFFI00004N

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 13,11
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 18,50
De Etats-Unis vers France
Destinations, frais et délais

5.

Johnson, Paul
Edité par Viking
ISBN 10 : 0670021059 ISBN 13 : 9780670021055
Neuf(s) Couverture rigide Quantité : 1
Vendeur
ACJBooks
(Staten Island, NY, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre Viking. Hardcover. État : New. 0670021059 !!!!This is a 1st Edition!!!!! This is a hardcover book with dust jacket. N° de réf. du libraire 250.X2

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 4,52
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 32,36
De Etats-Unis vers France
Destinations, frais et délais

6.

Paul Johnson
ISBN 10 : 0670021059 ISBN 13 : 9780670021055
Neuf(s) Quantité : 1
Vendeur
Castle Rock
(Pittsford, NY, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre État : Brand New. Book Condition: Brand New. N° de réf. du libraire 97806700210551.0

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 13,87
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 23,12
De Etats-Unis vers France
Destinations, frais et délais

7.

Paul Johnson
Edité par Viking (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0670021059 ISBN 13 : 9780670021055
Neuf(s) Couverture rigide Quantité : 1
Vendeur
Irish Booksellers
(Rumford, ME, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre Viking, 2009. Hardcover. État : New. book. N° de réf. du libraire 0670021059

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 26,53
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 11,10
De Etats-Unis vers France
Destinations, frais et délais

8.

Johnson, Paul
Edité par U.S.A.: Viking (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0670021059 ISBN 13 : 9780670021055
Neuf(s) Couverture rigide Quantité : 1
Vendeur
Books Galore
(Kansas City, MO, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre U.S.A.: Viking, 2009. Hardcover. État : New. Etat de la jaquette : New. Excellent condition. Clean, unmarked pages; firm binding. Language: eng Language: eng 0.0. N° de réf. du libraire 0406-BGHCST-BX102-12.7

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 21,86
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 18,50
De Etats-Unis vers France
Destinations, frais et délais

9.

Johnson, Paul
Edité par Viking (2009)
ISBN 10 : 0670021059 ISBN 13 : 9780670021055
Neuf(s) Couverture rigide Quantité : 3
Vendeur
Murray Media
(North Miami Beach, FL, Etats-Unis)
Evaluation vendeur
[?]

Description du livre Viking, 2009. Hardcover. État : New. N° de réf. du libraire P110670021059

Plus d'informations sur ce vendeur | Poser une question au libraire

Acheter neuf
EUR 29,46
Autre devise

Ajouter au panier

Frais de port : EUR 18,49
De Etats-Unis vers France
Destinations, frais et délais