Les informations fournies dans la section « Synopsis » peuvent faire référence à une autre édition de ce titre.
Members of all societies encounter disease and injury and develop social practices to cope with their effects. Social practices can also lead to disease and injury. The existence of medical problems and institutions to handle all of this can be regarded as a cultural universal (Brown 1991). Social scientists have described much variety in the way societies cope with disease and injury. There is a need for theoretical consolidation of this field. One of the principal tasks is to develop a frame of reference and a set of concepts in terms of which this variability could be organized and explained.
The basic material of medicine that requires explanation is that involving sickness and healing as these are configured and played out in different types of societies. As social and cultural phenomena, sickness and healing need to be studied from a holistic standpoint: The dialectic is between the physical environment, disease/injury as biological phenomena, and sickness and healing that are constructed as a function of the preceding and of social organization itself. This, in essence, is the enterprise of this book, with the added intention of interpreting changing aspects of medicine in terms of biological and social evolution. The purpose of this chapter is to discuss some fundamental issues, both methodological and conceptual, that pose problems for one attempting to develop a comparative approach to sickness and healing.
Visualizing the Material Content of the MedicalA clear hindrance to the development of a unified, comprehensive, and theoretical approach to the institution of medicine has been the sheer difficulty
of incorporating in one frame of reference the different kinds of disease problems that exist and the variety in the way they can be expressed in one society, regardless of its level of complexity or modernity. This would include the range of injuries, neuromuscular dislocations, anatomical fractures and contusions, and like phenomena that can befall people as a result of physical happenings. It would also include the range of infectious problems, systemic and local, that populations are vulnerable to, infections that vary as a function of a society's geography, characteristics of the physical habitat, dietary intake, level of social stress, and level of social organization and complexity. Besides infectious problems, there exist a plethora of disease processes involving metabolism, disorders of physiological function (e.g., gastrointestinal, respiratory, cardiovascular, genitourinary), and diseases of unknown etiology (e.g., cancer, multiple sclerosis, varieties of arthritis). Finally, one would have to include so-called emotional and functional medical problems that constitute a very large percentage of what physicians actually observe and are forced to treat in some way. This would include a large amalgam of somatically, psychologically, and behaviorally expressed ailments that in biomedicine today are not clearly classified from a causal standpoint. The amalgam would include a large segment of somatic conditions traceable to stress as well as most of the more clearly profiled psychiatric disorders, all of which prominently include somatic problems and very often still make their initial medical appearance in primary care settings because they manifest somatically and are so interpreted (e.g., depression, anxiety, dementia, psychoses of different types).
That these medical problems are dealt with by a large number of different types of biomedical specialists (clinical practitioners and public health oriented) and are thought of as different precisely because of the way they are defined, classified, and dealt with by the respective medical disciplines creates further difficulty for one intending to formulate a satisfying (i.e., comprehensive yet parsimonious) theoretical approach to medicine. At the very least, this heterogeneity of problems, although obviously neatly packaged biomedically, refers to highly diverse human phenomena of suffering that disable and incapacitate in different ways, that persist for different degrees of time when manifest, and that can be ameliorated from a symptomatic standpoint (short of acute surgical or pharmacologic intervention) to differing degrees and for different amounts of time. All of these problems, in short, create the formidable profile of morbidity and mortality that constitutes a society's medical burden and that one intending a theoretical amount of the medical must attend to.
A way of coping with the problem of the complex and variegated nature of the material content of the medical is to divide the theoretical labor and handle the material in different modes. From the standpoint of researchers in epidemiology and clinical medicine, the task is to identify the profile of medical problems that these scientists as well as physical anthropologists, archaeologists,
and paleopathologists equate with societies classified as to level of social organization and complexity as well as ecology or physical habitat.
Societies, of course, are not neatly isolated "things" one can study as though their approaches to the medical were unique. Nor is the structure of any society exactly like that of another, given the range of factors that can affect them. Rather, and despite apparent similarities and insularities, societies differ in any number of ways and are always in contact with each other. Medical phenomena in any one society and at one point in time reflect spread of diseases and cultural borrowings from other societies (McNeill 1976, 1992). A comparative, unified view of how societies construct and play out sickness and healing requires that one adopt an abstract frame of reference and a set of typologies that facilitate analysis.
One can assume that a particular "social type," namely, a society characterized by a distinctive set of structural properties, has associated with it a more or less distinctive profile of medical problems that constitutes the material content of the medical. In any theoretical account of medicine, this material would have to be in some way referenced since it constitutes the base out of which a people think about, approach, and cope with the medical. On the other hand, from the standpoint of a comparative social and cultural approach to the medical, the task is to rely on root concepts in terms of which one is afforded a way of fruitfully organizing and conceptualizing this material content of the medical of any particular society in social and cultural terms. In short, abstraction, reduction, and theoretical economy and precision are necessary here as well.
Illness, an individual's perception of a medical problem, sickness, the social construction of a condition of illness, disease, or pathology, what exists from a physical/organic standpoint, and healing, the range of medicines, procedures, and rituals by means of which a people try to prevent, undo, or minimize morbidity, are basic concepts that have been used in the past in medical anthropology and will be adopted here (Fabrega 1974; Frankenberg, 1980, 1986; Good 1977; Kleinman 1980). In later chapters, these basic concepts are supplemented by others that will serve to cast medicine in a more suitable theoretical frame of reference as the occasion demands.
The Problem of DataGood ethnographies of sickness and healing are basic requirements for theoretical discussions of medicine that are truly comparative. The field of medical anthropology contains many in-depth studies of sickness and healing. Several studies can be cited as classic examples (Glick 1963; Harwood 1970; Lewis 1975; Nash 1967; Ngubane 1977; Turner 1963). Recently, there has
taken place a surge of interest in the medical traditions of Asia. Characteristically, this interest has expressed itself in textual analyses of beliefs about sickness and healing practices, looked at as complex and elaborate systems of symbols (Dols 1984a; Farquhar 1987; Sivin 1987; Unschuld 1985, 1986a, 1986b; Zimmermann 1987). Emphasis on the richness of medical topics and their potential value for the study of rituals, spiritual concerns, and political happenings, staple themes in cultural anthropology, seems to have had the effect of directing efforts toward systematic in-depth studies (Young 1976).
Most ethnographies concentrate on only certain aspects of comparative medicine, for example, aspects of beliefs or meanings of illness, and not on concrete aspects of healing. Sometimes, the reverse is observed. Descriptive accounts predominate, making it difficult for one to evaluate how frequently a practice or an explanatory model is implemented. Ethnographers also differ in terms of orientation; some may prefer ritual aspects of healing, others semantic themes pertaining to illness, and still others the kinds of diseases that are encountered and their effects on the population.
With respect to literate traditions of medicine, such as those of India, China, and Islam, anthropologists' efforts overlap with and parallel those of historians. The anthropologists' interests obviously center on observed behaviors and contemporary practices, whereas those of historians center on what can be inferred from documents. The study of the social history of Western medicine has attracted a great deal of interest in the last fifteen years, far exceeding that of China, India, or Islam (e.g., Porter 1985; Wear 1992). Nevertheless, social histories of medicine deal with beliefs and practices and frequently rely on concepts and perspectives developed in anthropology. A basic limitation of these studies is the lack of material on the actual dynamics of behaviors associated with sickness and healing in earlier historical epochs. It is usually the case that important documents that reveal aspects of sickness and healing are translated and interpreted. Whereas this is indispensable for formulating some parameters, they simply do not address others. It is very likely that the actual processes of healing, including the kinds of organizations that may have existed among healers and the nature of relations between healers and their sick patients, are not recorded and may never be fully understood.
Since much of the data collected on sickness and healing are contemporary in nature, be these of small-scale societies or pertaining to the "great traditions," the problem posed by the competing, often dominant biomedical tradition is vexing. It is difficult to separate native cultural perspectives on medicine from biomedical impositions. The following questions illustrate this point. How much of a certain tradition's approach to healing is a result of the competition with or emulation of the biomedical? Were one to attempt to determine the kinds of sickness problems that a tradition handles "well," how is one to establish this if patients have resorted to other forms of healing? Since industrial capitalism is becoming the dominant political economic system in
the world, how do its tenets erode, undermine, and tarnish aspects of healing and medical practice that a more pristine tradition would have displayed?
These and related questions point to the kinds of data that are needed. A general theory about sickness and healing must overcome limitations in the quality and amount of data pertaining to medicine. Its goal is to explain how the medical is configured in different types of societies and how it changes in response to social, ecologic, and historical considerations. The study of sickness and healing has been strongly influenced by contemporary biomedicine and its cultural presuppositions. Consequently, theory about medicine must incorporate biomedical insights but also strive to handle biomedicine as but one (highly influential, to be sure) cultural approach to medicine. The approach to medicine in "pristine" societies not affected by biomedicine should ideally be given special consideration, although, as already noted, such types of societies are at best abstractions and approximations.
Delimiting the MedicalIn an analytic sense, one can delimit the medical as that which encompasses the problems of disease and injury in a society. However, this formulation immediately makes evident one's ethnocentric bias. Diseases as conceptualized in biomedicine and played out in contemporary societies are reasonably well demarcated. For the most part they are easily separated from the political, the legal, and the religious, as an example. One who studies such phenomena comparatively, however, learns quickly that in many societies problems of sickness and healing are not separated from other concerns but blend imperceptibly with phenomena that in European, biomedicine-dominated societies are institutionally separated.
Some problems in delimiting the medical in different societies can be illustrated. Many "diseases" of European societies may not be recognized or handled as sickness in other societies (Fabrega 1974; Payer 1989). The personality disorders of psychiatry constitute good examples of this, although similar generalizations can be made about other "diseases." Conversely, most "folk" illnesses are not easily equated with Western medical diseases (Johnson and Sargent 1990). However, that they can implicate traditional medical categories has been well documented (Guarnaccia 1990; Jenkins 1988; Topley 1970). Another example is provided by misfortunes involving domesticated animals or crop failures. In many societies these are conceptualized and handled in ways that are very similar to misfortunes of human sickness. Obviously people are able to tell the difference between sickness and other misfortunes; however, the point is that ways of understanding these diverse problems and attempts to undo their consequences share a basic ontology and epistemology in the culture. Something that an outsider might think of as "not medical" might be the
object of terminologies, explanations, and procedures that are also reserved for problems of sickness. Conversely, in modern Anglo-European-influenced societies, problems of obesity, unwanted facial or scalp features, undesired gender characteristics, or what is judged as an unattractive bodily organ may be the object of medical treatment. In this case, it would appear that sickness of morale and satisfaction with self-image or social confidence underlie and motivate medical treatment. In other words, something that would hardly be recognized as medical or sickness in many societies has taken on these labels in Anglo-European-influenced societies.
Finally, one can consider other items of social behavior that flirt with the medical. In many small-scale, elementary societies, conventions pertaining to hunting, foraging, and harvesting are invested with sacred directives and rules that operate as safeguards against sickness (and a host of other misfortunes, to be sure). What one could term "the medical" thus appears to be spread out, intruding into the social, political, and economic. As a contrast, one can consider the profound effects on thoughts and behavior that have taken place in modern society as a result of the way public health officials promoted the germ theory of disease. A host of attitudes and behaviors toward the body, hygiene, and private functions were altered dramatically and medicalized as a consequence of learning about the germ theory of disease. Given the profound influence that ideas of health and disease have on social experience and identity generally (Giddens 1991), it is difficult indeed to draw the line between health/disease concerns and those pertaining to identity, appearance, and behavior generally. It is obviously the case that in these instances, also, the medical is spread out and intrudes into highly social and private spheres of human behavior. In both instances, then, one can say that the boundaries of the medical are problematized.
The problem of delimiting the medical in society has to be viewed as part of the more general problem of reification of structures and entities as separate sorts of "things." An important tradition in the social sciences draws attention to the recursive nature of social life (Bourdieu 1977; Giddens 1984). Human action and practice is reflexively under review and influenced constantly by knowledge that it essentially reproduces. Problems of sickness and healing are, of course, no different, yet for one intending a theoretical approach to medicine both conceptual categories and culturally organized behaviors need to be dealt with abstractly and formulated systematically.
The problem of delimiting the medical poses obvious difficulties for one intending to articulate a comprehensive yet unified theory. How can one be provided with a frame of reference and a set of concepts for integrating, analyzing, and comparing the way people in different societies instantiate sickness and healing if the material is so fluid and variable that it seems to militate against valid categorization? There is, in fact, no way of avoiding these quandaries, although different strategies can be surmised.
One way is to adopt a frame of reference such as biomedicine in terms of
which one defines the medical and, with it as a measuring rod, proceed to analyze and compare how societies handle sickness and healing (the concrete social phenomena that instantiate disease and its effects). This epidemiological, public health approach has been undertaken and is not without its merits. However, since one starts out with a preconceived definition of the medical, one can only encompass phenomena covered by it and of necessity might have to exclude problems of sickness and healing that do not conform to biomedical definitions.
The approach suggested here is to start with abstract definitions of what sickness and healing consist of viewed in biological, social and cultural terms and allow them to identify and locate the medical across societies and cultures. Provided one is sufficiently specific, such a procedure can serve to delimit important areas of the domain of the medical that facilitate analysis. In this instance one may fail to include certain problems of disease (viewed biomedically) that are not conceptualized as problems of sickness and healing in a society. However, if the diseases produce bodily symptoms, physical signs, or behavioral breakdowns, it is very likely that they will be conceptualized as sickness and dealt with accordingly in the society and culture.
Measuring the Impact of Sickness in a SocietyMany factors affect the level of sickness in a society. What one could term bioecologic factors have received most attention. Research has indicated that complex genetic structures of populations, the ecology of its physical habitat, its way of procuring and processing food and water, and the level of social organization of a society, including in particular the density of its population and its social institutions pertaining to the availability of fresh air and the disposal of wastes, are all important. All of these and related factors will influence the level and kinds of disease that are prevalent, and the latter bear a direct relation to the level of experienced illness in the population and hence the impact of this in the from of sickness and healing on the members of the society.
Were one to limit oneself to measuring the level of malaria or dysentery in a society, measures derived from epidemiology would suffice to assess impact of sickness. However, were one to be interested in what sickness is made of as a social and cultural phenomenon, then what members of a population perceive as sickness and how they explain it, which entails orientations toward and understandings of the body and its functions as well as the problems of disease (which reflect purely bioecologic factors), all are relevant.
What is important to emphasize is the role played by social and cultural factors in constructing and reconstructing sickness and healing. This involves not only influencing and shaping threshold levels of what is to count as sickness, a basically cognitive/psychophysiologic matter, but also negotiating and re-creating
knowledge structures through social practices wherein experience and reality are reflexively monitored. These factors can be conceptualized to operate more or less independently from the purely bioecologic ones pertaining to the epidemiology of disease and injury and to changes in physiology. In other words, even if sickness and healing are conceptualized as rooted in biological factors and as having evolutionary implications, one must still study them from a comparative standpoint as socially and culturally constructed. There is much controversy here about how one is best to regard the biological and the cultural that will be dealt with in later chapters (Barkow, Cosmides, and Tooby 1992; Bourdieu 1977; Giddens 1984, 1990, 1991).
In the way of a generalization, if the social aspects of sickness and healing are emphasized, this means that the way in which they are thought of and played out in social conflicts or interpersonal relations can be studied comparatively with the strictly biomedical end of things kept separate. Moreover, a social and cultural framework allows one to consider under what conditions of social organization actors might be motivated (consciously or unconsciously) to express personal or social conflicts in sickness phenomena that are then played out during processes of healing. In this instance, then, the degree to which sickness is played out socially and interpersonally, a practice factor, influences the level of perceived sickness and end points of treatment, a more cognitive one; and the actual pathology underlying all of this needs to be recognized but can be left out of the analysis. Other parameters of sickness and healing that reflect cultural meanings could be studied, for example, attitudes about the body or remunerative aspects of healing. Finally, specific parameters of sickness and healing can be compared in different societies.
In summary, sickness and healing have a form and content that are a function of society and culture. Societies and cultures are, of course, not unitary things, nor can eventuations of sickness and healing be regarded as homogenous and representative "entities" even if they were. These complexities need to be kept in mind whenever medical phenomena are dealt with in terms of social types. Nevertheless, the interplay of cultural categories, social practices, and the reflexive, recursive nature of eventuations of sickness and healing need to be dealt with theoretically: Their diverse aspects in relation to types of societies need to be formulated and explained. A way of looking at sickness and healing comparatively so as to explain the diversity will be presented in later chapters.
On the Ontology of Sickness and HealingAn evolutionary perspective on behavior and adaptation, and, indeed, on the way physiological systems function, urges one to adopt a holistic, systems
theory point of view. In this light, an individual is judged to respond to environmental stress by means of changes in connected systems that describe him or her hierarchically. Sickness and healing as evolutionarily conditioned are thus constituted in a unity one could describe (given our linguistic bias) as psychosomatic and somatopsychic. What this means is that there is a natural tendency for problems of adaptation to be manifested in terms of physiology, emotional experience, and behavior. Biomedical science and the intellectual tradition that spawned it have created an emphasis pertaining to sickness and healing that has been characterized as ontological (Temkin 1963). The hallmark of sickness and the key target of healing is disease, a thing or object thought of as having a separate existence: an identity in anatomy, physiology, chemistry, and the like; a cause separated from itself; and an extension in time or "natural history." The ontological perspective or emphasis is said to constitute a watershed in the modern theory of disease and foundational to its understanding and epistemology (Rather 1959).
A key logical corollary of the ontological emphasis is that the entities and processes that make up disease have a physical essence and of course come to occupy and take place in the physical body. Given this interpretation, disease is thought of as somehow different from things mental, behavioral, or psychological. Dualism thus seems to be entailed by the Western epistemology and ontology of disease.
Dualism as a symbolic property of Western culture is structurally embedded in the contemporary practice of medicine. The education of physicians at the graduate and undergraduate levels and the emphases of the different specialties within medicine reflect a dualistic, mind/body dichotomy. Since physicians are socialized with this bias, their clients are reinforced for it, a cultural bias that is widely prevalent in the society to begin with. Dualism is thus a conditioning factor in the way sickness and healing are played out in Western society. Problems that have come to be conceptualized as "somatization" illustrate this point. This term refers to somatic problems that cannot be explained adequately in anatomic or physiological terms. The biological sciences stipulate a basis for disease that "somatization" problems fail to conform to or elude. One thus finds individuals sick with somatic problems that are compelling to patients and families but fail to meet criteria for disease. Such problems are now constituted as mental disorders, and their treatment is partly impeded because they carry a social stigma of mental illness that plagues patients with these disorders.
The basic holistic perspective on persons has implications for a theoretical approach to medicine. One is that to develop a theory, a unified schema and a comprehensive frame of reference is needed. A systems theoretic approach has been adopted. The second is that in constructing a social theory of the medical one is required to appreciate the dialectical interplay among the parameters of sickness and healing, on the one hand, and altogether different features of the
society, such as its organization/complexity and culture, on the other. In other words, holism implies interconnection, so that if a culture chooses to single out, say, purely the physical, then given psychosomatic mediation and the powerful shaping effects of social symbols, the material of sickness and healing will come to prominently display this facet. However, other components of the holistic material of sickness and healing, say, the emotional and mental components, remain present but masked, labeled differently, and expressed in a form that is dictated psychophysiologically by and consistent with the emphases conditioned by the semantics of the culture. One who attempts to construct a theoretical account of the medical is thus forced to analyze how the holistic basis of sickness and healing is shaped, modified, and labeled semantically in relation to "external" factors pertaining to society and culture.
In summary, from a theoretical standpoint, cultural conventions pertaining to ontology and epistemology give material content to sickness and healing. This material needs to be analyzed as meaningful and adaptive. However, to compare and formulate theoretically the cultural material of sickness and healing, it must also be studied in relation to scientific, etic understandings that are comprehensive and hierarchically organized.
Comparing Medical Knowledge StructuresTo be able to compare how sickness and healing are configured and played out in different societies, a way of categorizing and measuring these is needed. With a procedure for quantifying the medical in one society conditions are created not only for comparison across societies but also for predicting trends in the way the medical is likely to unfold across time and in relation to factors that impinge on the medical and are likely to alter its course.
One intending to use a classification of medical problems runs into problems of bias and cultural relativism. What frame of reference is to be adopted, and how can one validate it for comparison since of necessity it reflects the culture and political economic status of the analyst? Epistemological problems such as these when applied to medicine can essentially paralyze efforts aimed at scientific analyses (Spiro 1986), which of necessity require categories and classifications. With respect to sickness, a common scheme of classification pertaining to causes has included such categories as natural, supernatural; also, magical, religious, empirical, and scientific (Fabrega 1974; Johnson and Sargent 1990). These are obviously rather general and abstract categories. More detailed ones might include such things as physical environmental (e.g., heat, cold, level of moisture), social interpersonal (e.g., jealousy/envy, acts of hostility), actions perpetrated by spiritual/otherworldly agents (e.g., punishment by ancestors, godlike beings, malevolent spirits), psychological/mental states (e.g., hostility, worry, sadness), social/political happenings (e.g., work difficul-
ties, setbacks associated with subsistence), and finally ethnophysiological, which might include reference to distinct bodily structures (e.g., organs, conduits), substances (e.g., the humors, vital energies), or processes (e.g., fermentation, pressure differentials, movements and flows of materials of different types). A complementary set of semantic categories for describing the way healing is understood to occur and actually implemented can be surmised. These would include such things as the ways medicines are believed to work, the processes that need to be neutralized or energized in order to counteract the causes of sickness, or the actual procedures used by healers. Healing, in other words, entails carrying out physical, social, or verbal actions that are believed to set in motion distinct processes and/or mechanisms and these could be categorized semantically and as information.
A system of semantic categories provides a static classification of a society's knowledge structures pertaining to sickness and healing. These structures are of course continually reframed, restructured, and reinterpreted (Bourdieu 1977; Giddens 1984, 1990) and for one interested in capturing the essential "thickness" of the medical, such structures need to be handled conservatively. Systems of knowledge nevertheless provide one way of depicting the way the sickness and healing are configured and played out across time. Not only the richness of categories embodied in the knowledge system could be formulated but also which categories tend to carry the burden of explanation across time. A hypothetical occurrence of sickness could be conceptualized as embodying a quantum of uncertainty that members of a society attempt to reduce or eliminate by means of their knowledge structures pertaining to sickness and healing. The information required to accomplish this is embodied in its knowledge structures (Fabrega 1976a, 1976b, 1976c). The preceding illustrates one way of coping with the problem of comparing sickness and healing in different societies.
A system of classification for describing and comparing the way societies configure and play out sickness and healing could not easily deal with the effects that sicknesses produce; or, alternatively, with the efficacy of healing actions. Abstract schemes such as the ones suggested are just thatdevices for describing or quantifying what constitutes the cultural and social reality of sickness and healing of a people. They cannot provide information about physiological effects. For the latter, an entirely different schema would be required. Standard epidemiologic measures of mortality and morbidity immediately come to mind. The latter schema, of course, would be used to answer questions altogether different from those asked of a symbolic schema. Cultural and symbolic schemas pertain to how knowledge structures about sickness and healing are configured and used, whereas epidemiologic ones pertain to the effects of these structures on the lives of persons who use them. The one provides cultural information about social processes of sickness and healing, whereas the other provides biologic information about the effects of disease
and injury. It is the former schema that is developed here. In a complete theory of the medical, these two types of schemas and many others pertaining to the way knowledge structures work in a society would be required.
Medical PluralismWhat has been termed a theoretical perspective on medicine as a social institution involves the use of an explanatory frame of reference for comparing sickness and healing. Of necessity, then, it involves comparisons of whole societies , and this runs into the problem of the diversity of ways of thinking and acting with respect to the medical realm that exists in societies that differ in terms of social and cultural complexity. Is it possible to describe how sickness and healing are configured and played out in a (particular type of) society when that society seems to show a pluralism with respect to medicine?
Consider that a member of a small-scale society can explain illness in terms of several different causes by means of which he or she could make sense of the illness and seek to heal it. Insofar as each orientation is different in terms of content and required practices, is even this type of simple society "pluralistic" with respect to the medical? While any of a number of "pluralistic" interpretations are possible, together, presumably, they form a coherent part of the one cultural reality of medicine of the society. In other words, all members of the society share in this cultural reality and see alternative causal explanations as part of their one coherent picture of medicine.
An idea of medical pluralism makes more sense when an individual has access to more than one cultural approach to sickness and healing. Each approach need not constitute an organized system, leaving aside for the moment the problem of how one is to conceptualize what exactly is an "organized system" pertaining to sickness and healing (Press 1980). Suffice it to say that when individuals are able to distinguish between more or less separate ways of explaining and handling the medical, ways that differ in terms of basic propositions, explanatory mechanisms, procedures, and personnel, one can begin to speak more comfortably of medical pluralism.
Related problems can be given focus by considering how one will define "medical pluralism." To start with, one can entertain the following question: What would constitute the obverse of medical pluralism? "Medical singularity"? For example, could one ever describe a society that demonstrated a pristine, uncontaminated singular medical tradition or approach to sickness and healing? Even an isolated, family-level society could be said to have borrowed at least part of its knowledge of sickness and healing from nearby groups, rendering its approach somewhat eclectic. With time, it might evolve its own distinctive approach to sickness and healing but along the way is likely to assimilate elements from nearby groups.
Societies larger and more complex are likely to contain ethnic groups, lineages, or clans that have had different experiences with sickness and healing and hence are probably in possession of different bodies of knowledge and practices. Even an ethnically homogenous society is likely to be made up of groups that differ in terms of economic factors and given a modicum of complexity is likely to have access to different types of healers with approaches that differ. It is arguable whether one could meaningfully speak of a society with but one integrated, continuous tradition pertaining to sickness and healing. What one is likely to find instead are societies with several distinct approaches to the medical, each tradition constituting an amalgam of ideas, explanatory frameworks, and healing practices. The information of a tradition is likely to contain elements shared with other traditions found in the society, the latter linked to indigenous approaches, pagan themes, magical/religious tenets, and the like. In short, it is probably the case that medical pluralism is a constant feature of any complex society. Even the so-called great traditions (e.g., Ayurvedic, Galenic, Chinese) may themselves have been mutually enriched from borrowings at different points of their history. That they were found in societies characterized by having any number of lay, indigenous, magical/religious as well as empirical approaches to sickness and healing in addition to the "Great Traditions" has been well described (Dols 1984a; Leslie 1976; Unschuld 1985, 1986a, 1986b).
Given that medical pluralism is a social property of most if not all (certainly complex) societies, how is this to be dealt with in a theory of medicine? At the very least, it forces one to avoid speaking as though there existed one or even a dominant tradition of medicine. The control and dominance of biomedicine today, a dominance made possible partly as a result of a de facto state enforcement consisting of regulation, subsidy of research and education, and the co-opting of biomedical experts as policy makers/advisers, is unprecedented in the social history and cultural evolution of medicine. Competing traditions in the medical marketplace constitute the reality pertaining to a society's approach to sickness and healing. A theory about sickness and healing and medicine, more generally, must allow for the existence of medical pluralism and the resort to different traditions must be taken into consideration.
In comparisons of the medical across societies or within societies across time, the extent of pluralism, its architecture across social groupings, the degree to which traditions shift in importance in relation to other social factors, and the relative impact that different traditions have on the workings of other social institutions would ideally need to be taken into consideration. It is likely that parameters that make up sickness, such as definition of sick role, semantic meanings of sickness, or expectation of relief, will vary in relation to what tradition is selected. If more than one tradition is used, then the effect of conjoint use on these or related parameters should also, ideally, be considered. Simply describing how the different groupings of a society cope with pluralistic alternatives or
whether there exists a pattern in the way different traditions are used in the event of different types of sicknesses would prove illuminating in the comparison of sickness and healing across societies.
It should be clear that comparing the way persons orient to and make use of differing traditions of medicine in societies that differ with respect to degree of medical pluralism would constitute an enormously difficult undertaking. One way of coping with these and related problems is to focus on sickness and healing purely as abstract concepts and describe their properties in a generic way. Basic parameters in terms of which these concepts are configured and the semantics that serve to orient, give meaning to, and structure sickness behaviors and practices of healing would be emphasized. Of necessity, this requires formulating sickness and healing in terms of ideal actors of a particular type of society.
Social and Psychological Implications of Sickness and HealingMany of the issues discussed thus far can be looked at in terms of the social psychology of sickness and healing. Two related factors are worth considering. First, conceptualizations of sickness (and healing as well) do not operate or function in a vacuum; rather, they are integral to a people's sense of social reality, which itself has religious, political, economic, and ideological as well as strictly psychological overtones and dimensions. Second, to the extent that one's approach is concerned with cultural configurations, it requires taking into account how medical symbolization, medical action, and medical organization stand in relation to these other realms of experience, more specifically, how the view of the medical is affected by and affects the wider view of social reality.
As social, structural, and cultural characteristics of societies change, so do also myriad other characteristics. And all of them are dialectically incorporated in basic outlooks and orientations to the world and ideas about the meaning of an individual's life (conceptions of personhood). This is so because sickness underscores and heightens man's sense of uncertainty and thus brings into play how persons are seen to relate to the ultimate conditions of existence (Fabrega 1977). Of necessity, then, symbolizations pertaining to religion and cosmology are implicated in a basic way in the medical (Bellah 1964).
Religious symbols implicate the operation of governing agencies and the meanings they impart to social life. They also presuppose, shape, and are shaped by basic conceptions pertaining to human identity that can be expected to affect responses to sickness. This would include such things as conceptions of self, of objects of the behavioral environment, and of social activities that
provide meaning to everyday life. As an example, how unified or differentiated selves are felt to be determines how they orient religiously to this world; and both affect what can possibly be made of a condition of sickness and the opportunities presented by healing. Similarly, how persons are politically constituted, which is to say what they judge is possible in a civic, worldly sense, is not only intrinsic to religious action and experience but also critically shapes what persons and their healers think about a condition of sickness and possibilities for a return to health. Finally, the structures that comprise everyday life and experience, from the social divisions within the population through the way subsistence is patterned and carried out and on to the way reciprocation is contextualized, all affect the experience of sickness since they all determine what can be expected in the way of healing and how it can be accessed.
In summary, what has been referred to as a theoretical account of medicine as a social institution cannot but constitute a restricted enterprise insofar as its object is material that is also influenced by many other dimensions of a people's way of life. The theory's domain is social and psychological behaviors surrounding sickness and healing. The context of the medical underscores uncertainty and the essential powerlessness of human striving. The uncertainty of disease is colored by the society's way of conceptualizing such basic things as persons, the purposes of existence, the causes of human suffering, and the possibilities for betterment offered by worldly human actions. All that incorporates the sacred and the worldly is brought into play by sickness and healing. The topics relate to questions that are empirically contestable and theoretically highly controversial. As indicated earlier, a theory of sickness and healing should ideally incorporate material that only with difficulty can be separated from myriad other phenomena that condition human symbolization and action.
An elaborate historical account of the subject of illness considered in relation to social and cultural factors has been provided (Herzlich and Pierret 1987). Its emphasis is limited to Western societies and primarily those of the modern era, that is, orientations found in European societies during the eighteenth and especially the nineteenth centuries. However, this account contains material about views of illness in earlier European epochs, and it also includes empirical material that is contemporary. It draws attention to the central importance of epidemic diseases as setting the tone for how members of a society think of illness and orient to it.
One of its claims is that prior to the advent of tuberculosis during the nineteenth century (the "Ancien Rgime of Diseases"), sickness and healing viewed in terms of the self had played a comparatively unimportant role in intellectual circles and in the society at large: "It is our hypothesis that in the nineteenth century, and particularly with the advent of tuberculosis, the figure of the sick person crystallized existential and socially, assuming its modern form. This figure emerged as an individual with his or her concrete experience
yet also, and by the same token, as a social phenomenon. Henceforth the sick person was to be defined by his or her place in society" (Herzlich and Pierret 1987: 29).
It is not appropriate here to discuss more fully the many related and rich accounts of illness developed by Claudine Herzlich and Janine Pierret. It is relevant, however, to draw attention to how their orientation differs from the one followed here. They are primarily concerned with tracing the modern perspective of illness and the self. Moreover, they concentrate on intellectual and what one could term ideological aspects of illness. The widely prevalent (indeed, the dominant) symbols and social imagery about illness that are found in European societies are their principal concern. In this presentation, attention is given not to actual, descriptive properties of how illness and healing are played out (in Western or non-Western societies) but to a general, abstract account of such phenomena viewed from a comparative, evolutionary point of view.
Sickness and Healing and the Problem of Social Change and EvolutionA neglected topic in social studies of medicine is that of comparing sickness and healing and medicine, more generally, in different types of societies considered from a structural, macroscoiological point of view. Despite anthropology's and sociology's interest in social organization and the call for systematic comparisons, the appropriateness of whole medical institutions or traditions as objects for comparison does not seem to have been given much attention. A prevailing emphasis in the social sciences on meaning-centered analyses and on theories of practice, with persons and interpersonal networks seen as creating and re-creating knowledge, has naturally deflected attention away from the study of institutions as whole structures. That sickness and healing as social and cultural phenomena might show different characteristics as a result of differences in the size and complexity as well as culture of a society has not been systematically addressed. An emphasis on comparison and difference raises the question of how medical traditions might be expected to change and why.
Various terms have been used to designate the medical domain of a society. Some examples are health systems, sectors of health systems, medical systems, medical institutions, medical care systems or structures, adaptive health systems. The terms are not always used consistently, nor do they have similar meanings (Press 1980). One problem is the ambiguity of the concept "system" (e.g., how ordered and interconnected must a set of units be to qualify as a "system"?). Another factor contributing to ambiguity has been whether a medical or health "system" is handled as one of potentially several social units of a society (e.g., a structure, institution, or corporation) or whether it is used to
designate the total approach to medicine of the society as a whole and the separate medical units within this overarching system then being handled as sectors or subsystems (Janzen 1978a). All of the terms that have been used can be viewed as attempts to codify the variety and complexity of the social meanings about and resources pertaining to sickness and healing; or the health prevention/preservation rationales and procedures that exist in societies in a more or less ordered form.
A comparative approach to health systems was initially set forth vigorously by Fred L. Dunn (1976). He pointed out that health systems could be local (e.g., a particular lay, folk variety), regional (e.g., the Chinese, Ayurvedic), and cosmopolitan (e.g., worldwide, namely, the modern, Western, biomedical) and that regardless of type they all addressed basic factors related to health. He listed a number of factors, including health education, public health/sanitation, prevention, curing, and rehabilitation. Dunn emphasized that "each medical system evolved to meet a people's conception of their health needs" (1976: 142143) and that it did so to varying degrees depending on which of the several areas of health promotion and medical care one chose to emphasize. Importantly, Dunn drew attention to the fact that a health or medical system (he used both terms interchangeably) could meet disease/mortality/morbidity needs of a population (termed by him biological needs) and also needs pertaining to outlook in areas related to health and well-being, including such things as life satisfaction, social support, and joy (termed psychosocial needs). Systems of medicine also differed in terms of their integration and stability given the structure of the population and the features of the environment (he referred to this as a system's adaptedness) and in terms of their capacity to respond constructively to exogenous insults (he referred to this as their adaptability).
In his formulation, Dunn raised a number of intriguing questions about the way in which health systems function. Some examples are the following: "Is a medical system more likely to be adaptable-capable of responding to new insultsif it is closely associated with other medical systems? Or is it likely to become rigid and unresponsive in such circumstances, to protect its integrity? ... How, in general, are degrees of cultural homogeneity and heterogeneity related to the biological adaptive value of a medical system, to the capacity of a system to respond to new conditions, and to its ability to maintain psychosocial equilibrium?" (1976: 144). In this pathbreaking presentation, Dunn concentrated on characteristics of the Chinese, Ayurvedic, and Arabic-Persian medical systems. Although raising the question of variety, complexity, and differences in health systems, Dunn did not address the matter of how such systems change across time and dealt primarily with the contemporary scene, although his description and comparison drew on historical sources and examples.
An implicit and sometimes explicit (as in the case of Dunn) assumption that
exists in the minds of workers in this field is that these so-called social systems of medical care are each governed by cultural symbols and meanings, that they are more or less systematized and coherent, and that they provide individuals of a society with constructive ways of dealing with a medical problem or illness. This is why such social modalities of medical care are sometimes spoken of as "adaptive systems" and thought to promote "cultural healing" insofar as they provide for a way of cognitively, emotionally, and even psychosomatically shaping and controlling sickness and healing episodes (Kleinman 1978; Kleinman, Eisenberg, and Good 1978). At the same time, it is widely appreciated that the different sectors of a health system or different social systems of medical care of a society are not all consistent in a cultural/symbolic sense and, furthermore, can give rise to conflicts that impede the resolution of sickness episodes, perhaps even leading to the causation of sickness (hence the term "cultural iatrogenesis").
An important, neglected topic in this field of inquiry is that of conceptualizing and measuring change in "social systems of medical care." In other words, given that systems of medical care differ across societies and cultures, the question can be raised of differences across prehistory and recorded historical periods and also the question of how and why such social systems of medical care change. This particular area of the comparative study of medicine, also thought of as the historical sociology of medicine, has not received much attention from researchers.
One person who has dealt with this aspect of comparative medicine is John M. Janzen (1978a), who in his discussion of health systems as adaptive systems used examples of change in Zaire during the modern era. Besides underscoring the importance of this problem of change in health systems, Janzen provided useful guidelines for conceptualizing the social medical units of a society that could initiate and or be affected by this "systemic" change in approach to sickness and healing (termed corporate category and corporate group and roughly denoting the increasing degree of social definition and empowerment of a medical unit, such as that of practitioners of a certain type). He also discussed in a general way larger factors and processes that could also prompt change in health systems (e.g., political economic, historical). Janzen's efforts are perhaps the most focused attempts yet to concentrate on the topic of change in health systems. In doing so he of necessity drew attention to the need to concentrate on societywide events and processes. Arthur M. Kleinman has dealt in particular with the topic of complexity in medical systems and alluded to factors that could bring about change in them, largely by implication. His efforts have, like Janzen's, also involved the modern era. In his discussion Kleinman indicated that epidemiological factors must also be considered important in addition to historical and political economic ones.
The formulation of Zdzislaw Bizon (1976) carries forward the perspective of health or medical systems in terms of function and adaptation and offers a
way of conceptualizing social change and evolution. Although concentrating primarily on the workings of the medical profession during the modern era in European societies, his framework is applicable to all medical systems regardless of historical era or type of society.
Bizon indicates that the function of a medical system is to meet the goals for which it was set up and these consist of (and he is vague on this point) diminishing the morbidity and mortality associated with sickness and disease. Here, his formulation parallels that of Dunn. The goals are defined by the "environment," which in effect is constituted by the larger, suprasystem of which the medical system is part. The society and culture can be conceptualized as an important suprasystem, defining the functions of the medical system by providing the goals of improved health, decreased pain, restoration of function, and the like. These are targeted and managed by medical interventions and actions, which are defined as the basic units of the medical system.
The goals and functions of a medical system are framed in systemic and broad terms. In effect, they are properties of the society or of its dominant powers. Similarly, the medical system is framed in a corporate manner as consisting of groups with effective medical power. The medical profession is Bizon's classic example. However, these abstractly formulated goals and corporate units can be visualized in more concrete terms. Goals of the medical system are internalized in actors of the society who seek well-being through healing from the medical system that is actualized in its various healers. Sick persons in effect hold individual healers (implicitly or explicitly) accountable to the general goals and functions of the medical system as actualized in the actions of the healer.
Bizon introduces two important concepts in the study of medical systems. Function has already been considered and refers to a relationship between the medical system and the suprasystem or environment. The connectedness or fit captures this abstractly. The setting of goals is the key issue. Adaptiveness refers to the dynamic quality or ability of the medical system to maintain itself across time, not unlike the ideas of Dunn. In other words, as a result of change, evolution, or historical contingencies of any type, the suprasystem is constantly framing new functions and goals (or reframing old ones) in relation to changing needs and values of the population. A measure of adaptiveness of a medical system is how well it manages to keep itself functional in the light of inherent difficulties and/or inadequacies of its resources and capabilities. A basic assumption of Bizon is that only modern medical systems have been able to begin to meet their goals whereas earlier ones have been less successful, having to conceal and negotiate this matter. The medical system maintains adaptiveness through what Bizon classifies as adaptive mechanisms. These are classified in two categories that are not clearly separable. One consists of defense mechanisms, devices designed to protect the medical system from its dysfunctionality. Example of this are attempts to limit controls, obfuscate
goals, and promote new goals which in effect conceal its dysfunctionality. The other consists of social and political actions designed to promote itself. These enable the medical system to counterbalance and/or compensate for its dysfunctionality. Political action designed to obtain a monopoly is one way in which a corporate unit of the medical system can counterbalance its failures of resources and capability. Promoting defense mechanisms (e.g., "desirable" goals) as new definitions of a medical reality would constitute another example. "As a result of these activities, the profession [or any unit of a medical system] managed to counterbalance its ineffectiveness in influencing the natural, biological reality by exerting an effective influence on social reality; to replace the objective dysfunctionality of the medical system with the myth of its functionality in the social consciousness; to substitute for bio-technically ineffective action socio-technically effective activities" (Bizon 1976: 334).
One group of social scientists who also bring into focus the problem of social change in health systems is that which emphasizes a "critical approach" to medical anthropology (Singer 1989a; Singer, Baer, and Lazarus 1990). A dominant interest of these researchers is in some of the limitations and indeed sometimes the perniciousness of biomedicine and its exclusive emphasis on disease/organic factors and treatment to the detriment of an appreciation of how social factors consistent and supportive of biomedicine lead to the production of these diseases. A corresponding theoretical focus is on how political economic and class-related aspects of a society lead to systems of medical care that foster and perpetuate class systems and systems of oppression in a society.
In using critical theory when discussing society and medicine, these researchers draw emphasis, if only by implication, to the importance of this theory in providing a way of examining what factors bring about a restructuring of social relations of medicine within a society. In sum, critical theory provides a potential way of examining in some detail how health systems and aspects of sickness and healing change and "evolve." The analysis by Andrew T. Scull (1993) of how approaches to mental illness changed and of the corresponding growth of psychiatry during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries constitutes a landmark of this approach to the topic of change in health systems using critical theory as its basic approach. The rationale of critical medical theorists has also brought about an interesting and probing critique of medical ecological theory, a theory that takes account of the notion of health systems as adaptive systems (Singer 1989b). This critique has led to important reformulations of medical ecology aimed at meeting these criticisms (Armelagos et al. 1992).
Critical medical theorists are obviously aware of the idea that health systems are "dynamic," that there exist interests and factors that render such systems "functional," and that, by implication, health systems are capable of
"dysfunctioning" and changing. However, although possessed of a theory of social change and cultural evolution, these researchers have thus far concentrated primarily on modern and contemporary societies and on changes linked to biomedicine. Nonetheless, in underscoring the overriding importance of political and economic factors in bringing about change in health systems, critical medical theorists emphasize the need to pay attention to societywide factors, and in this respect their emphases parallel those of Janzen, Kleinman, and medical ecologists like George J. Armelagos and Dunn.
The preceding constitutes a brief summary of previous efforts aimed at explaining the question of complexity and change in the way sickness and healing are configured and played out in different societies. All of these efforts, insofar as they deal at all with questions of social change, are primarily concerned largely with contemporary or at least modern developments. The work of Rene C. Fox (1988a, 1988b) and Alexander Alland (1970) is to be contrasted to these efforts insofar as both of the latter are concerned not only with change in so-called health systems but also with the question of whether such systems can be said to evolve over long intervals of time. Fox and Alland both have brought into focus the idea of social and cultural evolution of medicine. Their efforts are nearly mutually exclusive in the sense that the interests and emphasis of each exclude but complement those of the other. Fox is exclusively interested in a sociological approach to the question of evolution and change in medical orientation and approaches consistent with stages of social complexity and does not address medical epidemiological/ecological issues. However, her analysis of how medical uncertainty has evolved is not only richly evocative but compelling and potentially useful to one interested in capturing medical phenomena "in the field," that is to say, as a way of conceptualizing how sickness and healing change and evolve.
Alland's (1970) work pertaining to medical anthropology is unique in that it focused directly on evolutionary questions. Alland drew on a tradition in medical anthropology (Polgar 1962, 1963) and on his interests in human evolution (Alland 1967), evolutionary theory, and cultural ecology. His contribution was that he emphasized the importance not only of different types of disease pictures linked to the environment but also of a population's behavioral systems (his apparent gloss for society, culture, and social structure) in affecting its (i.e., the population's) adaptation to the environment. He was thus clearly concerned with the relations between biological and cultural evolution as these processes were affected by the need to surmount problems of disease posed by the physical and biological environment of man. Alland correctly emphasized that to deal with the question of how populations cope with and surmount problems of disease, activities of individuals that are not limited to their conception of the medical needed to be taken into consideration. Political economic, ritualistic, and strictly subsistence issues together with medical
beliefs and practices needed to be brought into the cultural ecological equation if the goal was that of understanding how populations were adapted to the environment.
A very thoughtful and challenging theoretical exposition of the evolution and history of medicine has been provided by Timothy Johns (1990). His presentation differs from those of such researchers as Janzen, Kleinman, and Bizon and the critical medical anthropologists considered earlier in that biological evolutionary factors play a determinant role and empirical data pertaining to animal and human biochemistry are influential. The chemistry of plant and animal foods, the role of enzymes in intermediary metabolism, and the consequences of all of this for the meeting of energy requirements as well as for impairments in health status through toxic effects are his primary concerns. Johns sees the interplay of these factors as setting the stage for what he terms the chemical ecological context of subsistence, adaptation, and eventually medicine.
In his discussion of the origins and evolution of medicine Johns does not give concerted attention to social and cultural factors as do other social scientists who have been discussed so far. His formulation could be said to complement and elaborate that of Dunn and Alland in handling traditional medical practices as manifestations of an adaptive system for maintaining health. The actual behavioral characteristics of sickness and healing, including their meaning-centered features, are not a prominent concern. Rather, Johns gives primary attention to the relationship between social practices affecting nutrition (equatable as healing) and biochemical and physiological processes of organisms that affect health and well-being (Garcia, Hankins, and Rusiniak 1974; Rozin 1976, 1980).
I am giving considerable attention to the content of Johns's formulation here because it is complementary to the one I will be developing in subsequent chapters. During the evolution of the hominid line, food procurement strategies included reliance on a variety of plants that contained secondary chemicals, termed allelochemicals, that affected in a positive way the growth, health, and behavior of organisms through detoxication of plant allelochemicals. During cultural evolution, changes in human food procurement practices that decreased the amounts of these useful allelochemicals of plants are seen as related to the more elaborate use of herbal products for specific medicinal purposes. In effect, the latter are more concerned with the detoxification of the effects of plant and animal substances. Shifts to animal flesh and products, bacterial contamination of food, and the role of bacteria in the flora of the small intestine all mediate the chemical ecology of adaptation and health that points to the importance of herbal medicine.
Johns (1990) links, and seems to equate, the origins of medicine, which he defines as a cultural institution, to biological mechanisms of animals and higher primates involving ingestion of food substances and the special use of
plants for medicinal purposes (see chapter 2). However, he seems to at times equivocate in the way he relates biological and cultural factors in the evolution of medicine, sometimes judging that a continuity exists between these two types of processes and at other times suggesting a correspondence. The following quotes summarize the issue.
I argue that such use of plants is the biological prototype for human medicine. Similarly, the ingestion of clay to adsorb plant toxins has a biological basis. However, unless these behaviors have a cultural component, they are, strictly speaking, not medicine. When humans began to rely on learned knowledge and to communicate it from generation to generation, their use of plants evolved from a biologic, genetically determined behavior to a cultural practice. (Johns 1990: 258)
The overlap of culture and human biology makes it difficult to say which of our medicinal behaviors have a specific genetic basis. A more important aspect of our biology in relation to the evolution of medicine is our ability to learn. (Ibid., 274)
As plants and plant secondary chemicals preceded animal foods as determinants of human evolution, so it is reasonable to assume that herbal medicinewith its direct analogues in animal behaviorwas the original form of medicine. However, which of the surgical or pharmacological roads of medicine is of greatest antiquity is really a meaningless issue. Early rudimentary practices would have provided only a predisposition for the elaborate medical practices that arose late in history. (Ibid., 260)
Regardless of how he judges relations between biology and culture in the evolution of medicine, it is clear that Johns sees herbal medicine as the original human medicine and relates this to biological factors manifest in the hominid line of evolution.
The major part of Johns's treatise concentrates on chemical and nutritional factors related to food procurement and preparation practices as these might have affected early hominids. However, in a final chapter he discusses in summary fashion the actual evolution of medicine considered now as a cultural institution. For each of the major stages of cultural evolution, for example, the transition from hunter-gatherers to agriculture and from preindustrial societies to modern ones, Johns discusses how changes in living style, nutrition, food availability, exposure to bacteria and parasites, and cultural practices of eating, including the forming of conditioned and learned food aversions, affected health status and the need for herbal medicines. Implicit in his formulation, then, is how social structural factors connect with biological ones in affecting health status and the practice of medicine. Like William S. Laughlin (1963), he judges that the knowledge of anatomy that is needed for surgical medicine developed in association with hunting and butchering of animals but [relying on
suggestions of Landy (1977)] indicates that such knowledge could have been useful only as a last resort because of pain and surgical shock and infection.
It is useful to emphasize briefly here themes that I will be developing in later chapters which complement Johns's exposition. He leaves the actual behavioral material or content that make up sickness and healing largely out of focus. In other words, Johns is not concerned with the variety of practices, roles, institutions, and social psychological behaviors and the like that in their totality configure sickness and healing in any particular society, nor is he concerned with the transformations that have taken place during cultural evolution in the parameters of sickness and healing. I give primary attention to these sorts of themes. Similarly, although Johns is clearly motivated to link biological and cultural factors in the evolution of medicine, his emphasis on chemical ecology and his healthy empiricism appear to dissuade him from offering an actual methodology for conceptualizing the evolution of sickness and healing and for medicine more generally. It is precisely the incorporation of these quintessential social science themes with biological evolutionary ones as they pertain to the theoretical study of medicine that concern me and that I will be developing in later chapters.
There is little doubt that the fields of paleoanthropology, paleopathology, historical epidemiology, behavioral archaeology, and cultural materialism as well as chemical ecology have a bearing on any attempt at a comparative and evolutionary approach to sickness and healing (Cockburn 1971; Cohen 1989; Cohen and Armelagos 1984; Fabrega 1974; Harris and Ross 1987; Johns 1990). Researchers in this field have presented compelling generalizations about morbidity and mortality pictures in prehistoric and early recorded populations. They concentrate on the material base of the medical, and although they exclude from their consideration issues about culturally grounded "health systems" and behavioral issues handled here as sickness and healing, they nonetheless provide indispensable material that one interested in general, abstract theories of medicine has to make use of.
Scope of PresentationIt is important to emphasize that I do not attempt a comprehensive, descriptive account of how medicine has evolved and changed across pre- and recorded history. Ideally, such a full account would describe and summarize what is known about disease epidemiology and social medical practices in ancient populations in each of the major geographic regions of the world. Beginning with analyses of paleopathological remains of very early human societies in different regions, such an account would describe the presumed mortality and morbidity patterns of the population and go on to trace the effects of increasing social complexity and contact with adjacent societies on epidemio-
logical and clinical disease profiles. An interpretation of the interplay between strictly epidemiological factors, on the one hand, as compared to social and cultural effects of disease on behavior and adaptation as well as on social organization, on the other, would need to be discussed (based on inferences from representative, extant studies of hunter-gatherer and traditional, preindustrial societies) to complete the picture.
At the point when historical periods of certain societies were reached in such a narrative account, recorded information or actual observational data on the morbidity and mortality of disease might be available for some societies. Ideally, and balancing this type of epidemiological material, one would have available information pertaining to social medical practices in the respective societies. Thus epidemiological facts would be integrated with social and cultural facts. Such a "full" account of the evolution of medicine would summarize, describe, and analyze how the then-prevailing epidemiological pictures were expressed and dealt with (e.g., beliefs about disease and practices of shamanism and healing) in each of the major geographic settings of the world that were heavily populated.
A final chapter of this "full" story about the evolution of medicine would go on to describe the growth and development of biomedicine in early modern to modern European societies and end by analyzing its rise to prominence in the nation-states and its eventual spread over the world where it has either displaced or merely competed with the various indigenous medical systems. The political economic as well as scientific causes and implications of all of this would need to be discussed and, it is hoped, untangled.
The full account just presented constitutes a comprehensive, descriptive picture of the world history and evolution of medicine. For reasons already suggested, such an account is not possible. Paleopathology and historical epidemiology are fields that have grown considerably, but as yet the lack of empirical information and difficulties of interpretation of information that is available render generalizations difficult and tentative. A number of theoretical studies of the "great" medical traditions of antiquity are available, and this field of study is expanding to include aspects of medical practice, at least for European societies. However, little is known (and much may never be known) about how individuals actually coped with disease and injury and went about obtaining medical care in their respective communities in prehistoric and early historic groups. Information obtained in medical anthropology studies of contemporary "traditional" societies is available to complement this lack, but such information is naturally affected by modern conditions of living and by competition and modifications of ancient traditions brought about by diffusion and modernization.
In addition to the unavailability of pertinent data about epidemiology and social medical practices of prehistoric and early historic groups (deficiencies that with time will probably be lessened), there is the obvious difficulty of
being clear about the process of social evolution itself. Major social transformations have occurred in different geographic locations of the world and during different periods of time. However, a clear understanding of how some of these social transformations actually took place in any one region is not available and is also much contested. This is the case, for example, for that involving the transition from foraging/hunter-gathering to early agricultural societies and for that involving the shift from agricultural to urban societies, with the exception of many European ones.
This, then, constitutes an outline of what an empirically satisfying ideal picture of the evolution of medicine might look like and a review of some of the difficulties of studying it in a satisfying way. Something quite different is attempted in this book. A compromise is adopted. I handle the medical in terms of behaviors referred to as sickness and healing, for it is this interrelated set of meaningful human activities that, in my estimation, needs ultimately to be explained in any theoretical social and cultural account of medicine. Sickness and healing are viewed both as biologically evolved and as culturally evolved phenomena and a theoretical interpretation that regards them as expressions of a human adaptation is presented.
Instead of actually reviewing what is known descriptively about the medicine of different societies and epochs, a daunting and extraordinarily complex if not impossible undertaking (at this stage of historical and anthropological understanding), I rely very heavily on an evolutionary typology of societies and summarize abstractly how the medical is configured in each of the posited social types based on reviews of pertinent literature. It is important to stress that I aim to provide a conceptualization of and a methodology for the study of medicine from an evolutionary standpoint, not a "full," descriptively accurate account. Of necessity, I have had to be selective in what I discuss and analyze and, at times, abstemious as to details of how medical happenings were or are actually played out in each of the societies that my typology encompasses.
The chapters that follow complement and expand on the earlier approaches to the study of health systems that were reviewed above. In a most fundamental sense, any attempt to analyze the medical, socially and culturally, in relation to a particular "social type" is grounded on probable medical ecologic factors affecting morbidity and mortality. Principal attention is centered on sickness and healing as social phenomena, and an attempt is made to describe the ways in which these are conceptualized, behaviorally expressed, and played out in different types of social types. Second, emphasis is given to the fact that societies and cultures (handled here, descriptively, as whole entities possessed of complexity that problematize sickness and healing) change and evolve and that, as a function of this, sickness and healing as social phenomena also change, and in a more or less systematic way. In effect, the approach assumes the existence of change and evolution of health or medical systems reflected in the way sickness and healing are configured and played out. And
such systems are handled as units that analytically are separate from whole societies. However, primary attention is not on health systems or on the adaptive characteristics of these systems (viewed ecologically, epidemiologically) but rather on parameters of sickness and healing as these change in relation to social and cultural evolution. The analysis assumes that there exists an important relation between social and cultural evolution, on the one hand, and change or evolution in health systems, on the other. More specifically, that factors pertaining to sickness/healing can operate as potential causes of social and cultural evolution; and, conversely, that factors pertaining to societies (historical, political economic) as well as to the environment (climatic, soil depletion, epidemics) that promote social and cultural change or evolution can bring about change in health systems.
In table 1 is found a partial classification of types of societies that are given attention in later chapters. Some of the ethnographies and related medical studies that are used to draw generalizations pertaining to sickness and healing are listed in the table. The material constitutes some of the data on the basis of which comparisons of sickness and healing are carried out in later chapters. Material on the medical orientations of societies during the modern period and in the contemporary postmodern era are also discussed in later chapters, but the relevant material or "ethnographies" for these are presented in the text.
Some groups straddle categories. I handle the Aztecs (Ortiz de Montellano 1990) as a state and not as a regional polity (my civilization/empire) because their medical tradition seems to have been less influential regionally. This is contestable. Hunter and gatherer groups are typically classified as family-level societies, a convention I follow, but some show features that I regard as those of phase two of the evolution of medicine. For example, Aboriginal Australians (Elkin 1977), and the Batek (Endicott 1979) and Chewong (Howell 1989) of Peninsular Malaysia are all hunter-gatherers. In all three, most adult males are shamans (in the Batek, even females are shamans), which I link with phase one. Yet all three, unlike other hunter-gatherers, appear to also show a specialist healer role (which I equate with phase two). Among the Batek, strong feelings within the group can lead to sickness, and part of healing involves personal apologies and exculpations that seem to go with phase two, as is the case with the Gnau (Lewis 1975). All three groups show how knowledge of ecology, practices of health maintenance, and notions of personhood and well-being come together and function like formulas that are shared and that program behavior in ways that bear on concerns of sickness and healing. The material evokes a lucid picture of how "simple" yet also "advanced" and penetrating the earliest approach to sickness and healing can be and could have been structured during prehistory.
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Excerpted from Evolution of Sickness and Healing by Horacio Fbrega, Jr. Copyright 1997 by Horacio Fbrega, Jr.. Excerpted by permission.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.
Les informations fournies dans la section « A propos du livre » peuvent faire référence à une autre édition de ce titre.
Vos droits au titre de la garantie légale : Chaque consommateur de l'UE bénéficie d'au moins deux ans de protection au titre de la garantie légale pour tout bien de consommation vendu dans l'UE. Voir plus
Vendeur : Better World Books, Mishawaka, IN, Etats-Unis
Etat : Good. Former library copy. Pages intact with minimal writing/highlighting. The binding may be loose and creased. Dust jackets/supplements are not included. Includes library markings. Stock photo provided. Product includes identifying sticker. Better World Books: Buy Books. Do Good. N° de réf. du vendeur 18998604-75
Quantité disponible : 1 disponible(s)
Vendeur : Midtown Scholar Bookstore, Harrisburg, PA, Etats-Unis
Hardcover. Etat : Good. Torn/worn dj. Good hardcover with some shelfwear; may have previous owner's name inside. Standard-sized. N° de réf. du vendeur mon0000082975
Quantité disponible : 1 disponible(s)
Vendeur : Hawking Books, Edgewood, TX, Etats-Unis
Etat : Very Good. Very Good Condition. Five star seller - Buy with confidence! N° de réf. du vendeur X0520206096X2
Quantité disponible : 1 disponible(s)
Vendeur : Chaparral Books, Portland, OR, Etats-Unis
Hardcover. Etat : Very Good. Etat de la jaquette : Very Good. First Edition. First printing with full number line. The binding is tight, corners sharp. Light foxing on edges of text block & pastedowns. Text and images unmarked. The dust jacket shows some light handling, in a mylar cover. N° de réf. du vendeur SELfabEVO
Quantité disponible : 1 disponible(s)
Vendeur : North Country Books, Milton, VT, Etats-Unis
Hardcover. First Edition, First Printing. Hardcover with minor shelf wear, clean, tightly bound, contents unmarked, clean and bright paper. Dust jacket with minor shelf wear, clean. 364 pp. Perhaps an unread copy; in any case a new like copy. Near Fine in Near Fine dust jacket. N° de réf. du vendeur 13004
Quantité disponible : 1 disponible(s)
Vendeur : Bingo Books 2, Vancouver, WA, Etats-Unis
Hardcover. Etat : Fine. Etat de la jaquette : Fine. 1st Edition. hardback book and dust jacket in near fine condition. N° de réf. du vendeur 233510
Quantité disponible : 1 disponible(s)
Vendeur : Mooney's bookstore, Den Helder, Pays-Bas
Etat : Very Good. N° de réf. du vendeur 51DB53C0A6F3B9C
Quantité disponible : 1 disponible(s)
Vendeur : BennettBooksLtd, Los Angeles, CA, Etats-Unis
Hardcover. Etat : New. In shrink wrap. Looks like an interesting title! N° de réf. du vendeur Q-0520206096
Quantité disponible : 1 disponible(s)